15. Regarding health care, the acces
sibility and quality of the medical services in all the prisons visited (and the
IDF in Sofia) were as poor as they had
been in the past. Further, the quality of
medical recording had even worsened.
It is noteworthy in this respect that the
keeping of the register on traumatic
injuries had been discontinued at Sofia
and Burgas Prisons shortly after the
CPT’s 2014 visit. The confidentiality of
medical examinations and documentation was not respected. In addition,
in prisons, the initial medical examination hardly ever took place within the
first 24 hours after the inmates’ arrival,
as recommended by the Committee.
Such screening is essential, particularly
to prevent the spread of transmissible
diseases and suicides, and for recording
injuries in good time.
16. It should be added that no progress
was observed during the 2015 visit as
regards other issues of concern to the
CPT, such as prison staffing levels, discipline and segregation, and contact with
the outside world.
Concluding remarks
17. In its previous repor ts, the
Committee has taken due note of
the repeated assurances given by the
Bulgarian authorities that action would
be taken to improve the situation of
persons placed in the custody of the
police, or held in establishments under
the responsibility of the Ministry of
Justice. However, the findings of the
2015 visit demonstrate again that little
or nothing has been done as regards
all the above-mentioned long-standing
problems. This state of affairs highlights
a persistent failure by the Bulgarian
authorities to address most of the fundamental shortcomings in the treatment
and conditions of detention of persons
deprived of their liberty, despite the
specific recommendations repeatedly
made by the Committee. The CPT is of
the view that action in this respect is
long overdue and that the approach to
the whole issue of deprivation of liberty
in Bulgaria should radically change.
18. The Committee fully acknowledges
the challenges that the Bulgarian authorities are facing. In the CPT’s view, there is
a real need to develop a comprehensive
prison policy, instead of concentrating
exclusively on material conditions (which,
as should be stressed, have only improved
to an extremely limited extent). Having in
place a sound legislative framework is no
doubt important. However, if laws are not
backed by decisive, concrete and effective
measures to implement them, they will
remain a dead letter and the treatment
and conditions of persons deprived of
their liberty in Bulgaria will deteriorate
even further. As regards the treatment
of persons detained by law enforcement
agencies, resolute action is required to
ensure the practical and meaningful operation of fundamental safeguards against
ill-treatment (including the notification
of custody, access to a lawyer, access to a
doctor, and information on rights).
The Committee’s aim in making this
public statement is to motivate and
assist the Bulgarian authorities, and in
particular the Ministries of the Interior
and Justice, to take decisive action in
line with the fundamental values to
which Bulgaria, as a member state of
the Council of Europe and the European
Union, has subscribed. In this context,
the CPT’s long-standing recommendations should be seen as a tool that
helps the Bulgarian authorities to identify shortcomings and make the necessary changes. In furtherance of its
mandate, the Committee is fully committed to continuing its dialogue with
the Bulgarian authorities to this end.
Appendices ► Page 73
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents