BACKGROUND
draft legislation. However, this has so far not been
possible due to its staff and financial resources being
overstretched.
Pursuant to the rules set out in the OP-CAT, the
Federal Government and the Länder have granted the
National Agency the following rights:
•
Access to all information concerning the
number of persons being deprived of their
liberty at places of detention as defined in
Article 4 of the OP-CAT, as well as the
number of places of detention and their
location;
•
Access to all information referring to the
treatment of these persons as well as their
conditions of detention;
•
Access to all places of detention, their
installations and facilities;
•
The opportunity to hold private interviews
with persons deprived of their liberty
without witnesses, either personally or,
where deemed necessary, through an
interpreter, as well as with any other persons
whom the national preventive mechanism
believes may supply relevant information;
•
The liberty to choose the places they wish to
visit and whom they wish to interview;
•
To maintain contact with the UN
Subcommittee on Prevention of Torture, to
send it information and to meet with it.
approached the then Chair of the Conference of
Ministers of Justice of the Länder and requested that
the matter of increasing funding for the National
Agency be addressed.
At its Spring Conference in June 2013 the Ministers
of Justice agreed the following:
“The Ministers of Justice are in favour of providing the
Joint Commission of the Länder for the Prevention of
Torture with additional experts in the field of the
deprivation of liberty who do not fall within the
responsibility of the judicial authorities. To that end they
intend to increase the number of members working on an
honorary basis to eight in total.
“To fund this increase the Ministers of Justice request that
the Land holding the chair contact the Standing Conference
of Ministers of the Interior and the Standing Conference of
Ministers of Labour and Social Affairs to negotiate their
financial involvement.
“The Ministers of Justice ask the Land holding the chair
of the Standing Conference of Ministers of Justice to submit
a recommendation for a decision.”
In October 2013 the German Medical Council sent a
letter to the Minister of Justice of Saarland, who at
the time was chair of the Standing Conference of
Ministers of Justice, to draw attention to the need to
increase the resources available to the Joint
Commission, a need it felt to be “urgent”. Neither the
Standing Conference of Ministers of Labour and
Social Affairs nor the Standing Conference of
Ministers of the Interior reached decisions regarding
the National Agency at their autumn meetings held in
November and December 2013, respectively.
The National Agency has an annual budget of
EUR 300,000, of which EUR 100,000 is made
available from the federal budget and EUR 200,000
from the budgets of the Länder on the basis of a
distribution formula known as the “Königstein Key”.
In accordance with Article 21 para. 1 of the OPCAT, no person who has communicated any
information to the National Agency may be
prejudiced in any way or subject to any sanctions. The
members and staff of the National Agency are obliged
to maintain secrecy beyond their term of office.
1.3 – FINANCIAL AND HUMAN RESOURCES
Given the current level of staffing and funding, the
Federal Agency and the Joint Commission are unable
to fulfil their official mandate of carrying out regular
visits. In May 2013 the Federal Government
appointed a Deputy Director to the Federal Agency,
thereby doubling its membership.
Despite expanding the Federal Agency’s
membership, the National Agency’s capacities (six
members and funding for three research assistants and
1
one administrative assistant) are insufficient. The
National Agency is thus unable to visit psychiatric
hospitals, homes for the elderly and nursing homes.
The Chair of the Joint Commission therefore
1
See the National Agency’s Annual Report 2012, p. 7, available in
German and English at:
www.nationale-stelle.de
15
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents