III. ACCOUNTABILITY AND THE RIGHTS OF VICTIMS
interests that States are entitled—and even obliged—to bring proceedings
against the perpetrator, regardless of the location of the crime and the
nationality of the perpetrator or the victim.”124
Sometimes the extent of a State’s accountability obligations will have to
be determined in the framework of the jurisdictional competence of an
international tribunal or court. The jurisdiction of the International Criminal
Court, for example, applies to the crimes set out in its Rome Statute
committed by nationals or on the territory of a State party to the Statute—or
when the United Nations Security Council so decides.125 However, in view
of the complementarity principle enshrined in the Rome Statute, the Court
can exercise its jurisdiction only when the competent State is unwilling
or unable to prosecute. States therefore retain the main responsibility for
trying alleged perpetrators and only in certain cases may prosecution be
transferred to the International Criminal Court.
4. Amnesties126
Opportunities for accountability and justice most often come at the end
of an armed conflict. Amnesty for violations committed during the conflict
can become a key condition for obtaining a ceasefire or peace process,
raising challenging questions as to the extent to which the granting of
amnesty is compatible with international human rights and humanitarian
law requirements of accountability and the rights of victims.
It is generally held that amnesty laws that foreclose prosecution of war
crimes, genocide, crimes against humanity and gross violations of human
rights, such as extrajudicial, summary or arbitrary execution, torture,
and enforced disappearance, are inconsistent with States’ accountability
Mary Robinson, “Preface”, in Universal Jurisdiction: National Courts and the Prosecution
of Serious Crimes under International Law, Stephen Macedo, ed. (Philadelphia,
University of Pennsylvania Press, 2004).
125
Rome Statute, art. 5.
126
For further information, see Rule-of-law Tools for Post-conflict States: Amnesties (United
Nations publication, Sales No. E.09.XIV.1). Available from www.ohchr.org.
124
85
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents