Places of Medium-Term Deprivation of Liberty
in their clothing for washing during their time at the establishment. This
shortcoming means that inmates wash their clothes using the means available to
them (they are provided with soap and use sinks, if there are any, or even
washbasins), having to dry the clothes in their dormitories, on makeshift laundry
lines. Accordingly, a call has been made for all the CIEs to be provided with the
same laundry services as those currently available in Barcelona, Madrid and at the
establishment in Tarifa (Cadiz). In the case of Malaga, the information provided
at the time of the visit was that the CIE would be provided with an industrial
washing machine and a dryer.
271. The CIEs have communal recreation areas, whose comfort and state of
Deficient state of repair of
repair are deficient. They have a television, but there is not enough furniture and
communal recreation areas
recreational equipment, bearing in mind that this is the area where the inmates
have to spend almost the entire day. In the case of the CIE in Malaga, the presence
of load-bearing walls means they cannot be knocked down to enlarge the
communal areas, so the canteens are being used as day rooms.
272. In order to permit inmates to exercise and enjoy the open air, there are
The CIEs have yards but not
yards in all the CIEs, but these do not always have sports facilities or equipment.
all of them have sports
In most cases, they also lack a covered area enabling the yards to be used on rainy
facilities and equipment
days or in adverse weather conditions. The appropriate indications have been
made at each CIE to rectify the situation described. The CIE in Murcia reported
that the inmates do not go out into the yards during the afternoons, as there have
been several escape attempts, and there are not enough guards to control this.
This situation needs to be resolved, as it involves an excessive deprivation of
liberty that increases its duress.
273. Inmates may be attended by a minister of their faith, although the
The CIEs visited do not have
CIEs visited do not have a specific area set aside for worship (one was
a specific area for worship
initially foreseen at the CIE in Murcia but it is now used as a storage area).
Nevertheless, it was noted that whenever so requested, an area was set aside
for these purposes.
274. No communications problems have been detected at the CIEs inspected in
Each CIE regulates visits by
terms of public transport. Visits by family members and friends are arranged into
family members and
different time slots and frequencies depending on each CIE. This matter gives rise
to numerous complaints and is monitored by the Ombudsman, being also the
focus of attention of the judges overseeing detention in CIEs. Certain CIEs, such
as Malaga, find it difficult to comply with the visiting times specified in the
friends. The Ombudsman
can see no reason for the
use of separating screens
that stop any physical
contact
regulations due to problems of space. This is an area that very clearly highlights
the shortcomings of the infrastructures themselves and even the police force’s
compliance with the legal standards set out for a centre and the deprivation of liberty
that must not be seen as a prison sentence. Generally speaking, the Ombudsman can
THE OMBUDSMAN OF SPAIN
119
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents