of radicalisation. For this reason the Committee recommends that the authorities
review their treatment of prisoners considered at risk of being radicalised or of
radicalising others. The French authorities’ response gives a detailed description
of the strategy and measures deployed and envisaged to prevent or counter the
effects of radicalisation in French prisons.
33. The Committee also raises its serious concern about the situation of inmates
receiving treatment in hospital in unacceptable conditions, such as extensive resort
to ankle-cuffs and the frequent presence of escorting custodial staff, including during
surgery or childbirth. In response, the French authorities give a detailed account of
the policy in place for the practical operation of prisoners’ hospital visits, and also
refer to the setting-up of a working group bringing together penitentiary and public
health officials which will carry out a study on the use of ankle- and hand-cuffs and
the presence of custodial staff during medical or gynaecological consultations.
34. In its report the CPT also recommends action to prevent excessive use of force
by prison staff in the hospital psychiatric ward designed for prisoners (UHSA - unité
hospitalière spécialement aménagée) in Toulouse.
35. The CPT welcomes the establishment of treatment plans for each individual
patient in psychiatric establishments, but it raises questions about the relatively
high level of psychotropic medication delivered to some patients in Albi psychiatric
ward for challenging patients (UMD – unité pour malades difficiles). In response, the
French authorities acknowledge the difficulty of treating certain patients who have
developed increased resistance to certain psychotropic drugs and present a high risk,
and commit to pursuing their efforts to reduce the use of combined psychotropic
drugs.
36. The frequency and length of mechanical restraint (without proper medical
supervision) is also of concern in the psychiatric establishments visited by the CPT’s
delegation. Welcoming the introduction of legislation on means of restraint, the
Committee regrets, however, that the text makes no reference to chemical restraint.
37. The CPT visited for the first time in France a long-term care institution for the
elderly, the Marcel Riser facility (Gérard Marchant hospital). One of the recommendations contained in the report concerns the improvement of living conditions for
residents. In their response the French authorities describe the improved conditions
to be afforded in the new facility, on which construction began in September 2016
and to which residents would be transferred as of March 2018.
Report and response published in April 2017
(CPT/Inf(2017)7 and CPT/Inf(2017)8)
Report on the periodic visit to Germany in November-December
2015 and response of the German authorities
(situation of persons in police custody, in prison and in civil or forensic psychiatric institutions in several Länder)
38. Overall the CPT’s report praises progress made to improve the treatment
of persons deprived of their liberty, but also finds striking contrasts between
Publication highlights ► Page 17
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents