Correctional institutions
Communicating with patients who speak foreign languages – Hall
Regional Hospital, Graz Süd-West Regional Hospital
Hall Regional Hospital
During a visit to the forensic ward of Hall Regional Hospital in November 2016,
the NPM addressed the problem of communicating with patients who speak
foreign languages, among other problems. During an attempt to converse
with a detainee in the forensic ward, the commission learned that the patient
could not speak German or English.
No ability to
communicate
The on-duty nursing staff also could not communicate with the patient. The
caregivers confirmed that an interpreter is available in principle. However, it
is not possible to call in the interpreter before every nursing activity, since he
is not present around the clock.
Both Tiroler Kliniken GmbH and the Federal Ministry pointed out that it is
solely within the medical responsibility and competence of the clinic to
decide whether and how the clinic staff communicate with a patient before,
during and after placing him or her in restraint. There is no requirement that
verbal communications should be in the affected person’s mother tongue.
A close relationship can also result from relationship-oriented non-verbal
communication, such as sign language, facial expressions or gestures. In the
hospital’s view, the constant presence of interpreters constitutes a significant
security risk since they are not sufficiently familiar with the situation in a
forensic ward and with the patients.
Image folder and video
interpreting
However, the NPM’s criticism was taken into account since the nursing staff
made a folder with pictograms. It contains symbols and pictures of everyday
items and situations with the corresponding German word or phrase.
Moreover, an additional video interpreter account was ordered for the relevant
ward. Video interpreter is available within a short period of time, as was
demonstrated during a follow-up visit.
Forensic ward at Graz
Süd-West Regional
Hospital
During a visit to the forensic ward at Graz Süd-West Regional Hospital, it was
also made clear that psychiatric treatment and therapy require a common
understanding of a language. Graz-West Regional Hospital promised to
intensify its efforts to utilise interpreters on a permanent basis.
The NPM made reference to the video interpreting system, which has become
established throughout Austria in the medical areas of all correctional
institutions. The NPM recommended that Styrian Hospitals Limited Liability
Company (Steiermärkische Krankenanstaltengesellschaft) considers the
adoption of this system.
XX
A video interpreting system should be established in public hospitals.
XX
If it is not possible to communicate with a patient due to a language barrier, an
interpreter should be called in or pictogrammes should be used.
112
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents