Hospitals and psychiatric institutions
Patients plausibly claimed in interviews with the commissions that they were
threatened with restraint if they questioned their medication or did not comply
with the prescribed therapy. They were also urged to take their medication
in a very aggressive manner (“If you do not take the medicine, then…”).
One patient reported that she was threatened with the cancellation of her
forthcoming discharge from the facility if she did not clear away the trays.
Threat and restraint
The interviewed patients, some of whom have been admitted to a psychiatric
ward several times, find such treatment degrading and frightening.
The NPM is insistent that the nursing staff should be sensitized in general
about the use of such verbal pressure. Pertinent information from the NPM is
taken very seriously by the hospitals and is the basis for meeting with staff in
order to underline the significance of an appreciative approach when dealing
with patients.
Ultimately, violence to patients can be accounted for in treatment methods that
are difficult to see objectively. An unfriendly look, roughness when assisting
with personal hygiene or apparent impatience during care treatments can
thus be perceived by the patients as intimidating or degrading.
The NPM also observed that the prescription of so-called PRN medication
often fails to comply with the regulations: amount, dose, channel and time of
administration must be recorded in the patient documentation by the doctors
authorised to write prescriptions. Whilst the administration of medication is
a medical activity, it can be delegated to qualified nursing staff within the
framework of a multi-professional area of competence.
Precise prescription
of PRN medication
necessary
Prescriptions that do not include a specified time plan are only permissible
if the criteria for assessing the time and the dose of the medication to be
administered are clear, unequivocal and transparent according to medical
standards. It must be possible to preclude an inadmissible diagnostic or
therapeutic activity by the nursing staff. However, the documentation viewed
contained some vague information (such as “additionally for severe agitation”
or “for agitation”). The consequence of such unspecific prescription of a PRN
medication is naturally that the nursing staff have a relatively large amount
of leeway. It cannot be ruled out that medication is used hastily to sedate
patients without first trying milder measures. This kind of approach can also
allow hidden violence to occur which patients can perceive as a “sanction” in
extreme cases.
47
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents