Correctional institutions
2.5.5
Health care
2.5.5.1 Tobacco consumption and protection of non-smokers
Tobacco consumption in facilities of the penitentiary system and facilities
for the detention of mentally ill offenders and the lack of protection for nonsmokers constitute a national problem. There is an above-average number
of heavy smokers in facilities for the detention of mentally ill offenders and
others. Moreover, the majority of inmate cells in correctional institutions are
cells for smokers, and some are severely polluted by nicotine. The NPM also
frequently found that smoking and non-smoking inmates were held together
in cells for multiple inmates.
Acute health risk
The negative health consequences of active and passive tobacco smoking are
generally acknowledged. It is common knowledge that inhaling tobacco smoke
hanging in the air is referred to as “passive smoking”. Passive smokers suffer
the same acute and chronic illnesses as active smokers – only such illnesses
are less extensive and less frequent. Tobacco smoke that is inhaled through
passive smoking contains the same poisonous and carcinogenic substances
as the smoke inhaled by smokers. Therefore, passive smoking also causes
numerous illnesses, some of which are serious.
Around-the-clock
exposure to nicotine
A special health risk exists when persons who suffer from a pre-existing illness,
which is worsened by smoke, are housed together with smokers. Except for an
hour of outdoor exercise, inmates remain in cells polluted by nicotine for up to
23 hours per day. In some cases, the ventilation is very limited.
The prison administration is responsible for the inmates’ health. The Federal
Ministry assured the NPM that facility management has consistently
attempted to separate smokers and non-smokers, unless the affected persons
were opposed to this.
At the same time, the Federal Ministry conceded that separation cannot always
be guaranteed. This is explained by the high occupancy of many correctional
institutions in conjunction with the shortage of space. In addition, there are
the restrictions that accompany different forms of detention (such as first-time
imprisonment or pre-release) and the requirement to separate accomplices in
court prisons. Inmates often have other interests – such as placement based
on nationality – which are taken into account, when possible. However, these
interests are secondary in the case of a pre-existing medical illness.
Not to be held in the
same cell
Although it is understandable that smoking plays a different role in detention
than in free society and providing separate accommodations can pose a
challenge, the protection of non-smokers may not be disregarded. Therefore,
the NPM recommends that non-smokers not be held together with smokers in
cells for multiple inmates. Persons who do not smoke should be protected from
118
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents