5 – PRISONS
In 2018, the National agency visited Leipzig
Prison and Hospital.
5.2.2 – Furnishings and design
In some cases, the walls of the prison cells were
extremely dirty and the furniture was worn. The
leisure areas were bare and were used for various
other purposes – for example, as storage rooms.
In addition, the prison cells did not have any
curtains. The prisoners resorted to makeshift
solutions in order to ensure privacy and to
protect themselves from incoming light.
5.1 – POSITIVE EXAMPLES
The National Agency made the following
positive observation during its visit:
Leipzig Prison was equipped with a suicideprevention room for individuals who have
expressed suicidal thoughts without exhibiting
acute suicidal tendencies. The suicide
prevention room focuses on providing
treatment, and not only on preventing self-harm.
The individuals occupying the room are
provided with psychological care and are subject
to continuous monitoring. If necessary, an
examination can be carried out by a psychiatrist,
who can then initiate a transfer to a psychiatric
clinic. The room was pleasantly furnished, with
bars covering only the lower part of the window.
One side of the room was glazed and fitted with
a window, which made it possible to contact
staff in the adjacent room. Furthermore, there
were additional blinds on the glazed side, which
give the affected person the option of increasing
their level of privacy.
It should be possible to darken the cells and
prevent people from seeing into them from the
outside. At the same time, prisoners should be
able to adjust the level of light themselves.
Prisons should have a pleasant design and
should be renovated where necessary.
5.2.3 – Specially secured room
At Leipzig Prison, both the frequency and, in
some cases, the duration of occupancy in the
specially secured cell were very high compared to
other prisons. Moreover, the specially secured
cell did not have any seating.
When using specially secured cells, the
principle of proportionality must be adhered to
– both with regard to the decision to order the
measure and the duration of its application.
Where the period of detention lasts for several
hours or days, it is inhumane to force prisoners
to stand or sit on the floor. In a similar facility,
the National Agency observed that covered
foam dice were used as seating. This would be
desirable for longer periods of detention.
5.2 – FINDINGS AND
RECOMMENDATIONS
The
visited
facility
was
given
recommendations on the following main topics:
5.2.1 – Medical care
Prisoners described the medical care provided
at Leipzig Prison as inadequate, despite the fact
that there is a hospital directly adjacent. There
were also complaints of pain being treated
inadequately or not being treated at all.
5.2.4 – Drug tests
At Leipzig Prison, drug tests were carried out
using urine samples. For urine samples provided
by individuals who have received substitution
treatment, an additional person is not
immediately present. However, all other urine
samples were subject to visual checks by general
prison staff.
Prisoners are entitled to comprehensive and
84
adequate medical care. Facilities must ensure
that this is provided.
During its visits, the National Agency
encountered various drug testing methods which
minimised the degree of interference with
84
ECHR, Wenner v. Germany, judgment of 01/09/2016,
Application no. 62303/13, margin no. 58
68
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents