17
Selected topics from 2016
Body searches
– balancing security
and dignity
All of the sectors visited by the National Preventive Mechanism (NPM)
conduct body searches. In many cases, these measures involve a serious
interference in the integrity of an individual, and therefore require a
clearly defined basis in law. Findings from the NPM’s visits show that the
practical implementation of body searches varies greatly, even among
institutions that apply the same legal provisions.
Each sector covered by the Parliamentary Ombudsman’s preventive mandate, such as police custody
facilities, prisons, mental health care institutions and
immigration detention centres, have their own legal
provisions that provide authority for body searches.
—
A common aim of the
legal provisions is to prevent
people bringing objects or
substances with them that
are illegal or that may be
used to injure themselves
or others.
—
1 The Mandela Rules, Rule 50.
A common aim of the legal provisions is to prevent
people bringing objects or substances with them that
are illegal or that may be used to injure themselves or
others. In the immigration field, body searches may be
used to try to determine a person’s identity.
International human rights standards provide legal
authority for body searches in different contexts,
and they also set requirements for when and how
the intervention should be implemented. In the field
of correctional services, the UN’s revised Standard
Minimum Rules for the Treatment of Prisoners (the
Mandela Rules) state that searches of prisoners and
cells shall be carried out in a manner that is respectful
of the inherent human dignity and privacy of the
individual being searched. Such measures shall be
implemented following an assessment of proportionality, legality and necessity.¹ The European Court
of Human Rights has pronounced several judgments
that have particularly focused on the most invasive
form of body searches, where the person is fully
undressed and in some cases also asked to squat
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents