E/CN.4/1989/15
page 13
56. On 19 October 1988, another letter was addressed to the Government of
Indonesia transmitting information alleging that on 25 April 1988 several
hundred Moluccans had been arrested by the military police in the Moluccas.
Finally, it was reported that Pieter Nasarany was detained on 13 July 1988 in
Piru, a village in West Seram Island. He was allegedly held incommunicado and
subjected to torture.
57. On 22 July 1988, the Government of Indonesia informed the Special
Rapporteur that Mrs. Indrawati had been arrested by the police on charges of
arson in October 1987. During her detention she had fallen ill and been
admitted to the Sleman Public Hospital. According to her medical examination
there was no sign of violence on her body. She was no longer detained as
evidence to be forwarded to the court by the District Attorney was lacking.
Furthermore, the Government submitted information concerning Binsar, rejecting
the allegation that his paralysis was a result of beatings by prison officers
and stating that it was a result of high fever and feebleness of the legs. He
had been released on 28 October 1987, but was still under the supervision of
the Child Supervisory and Guidance Agency. His health had been restored and
he had regained his ability to walk and speak without difficulty.
58. By a letter dated 30 November 1988, the Government of Indonesia rejected
the accusation that several hundred Moluccans had been detained for the last
four months in Molucca. It stated that, after a thorough investigation
conducted by the authorities, the accusations were found to be factually
untrue. Referring to the case of Pieter Nasarany, the Government informed the
Special Rapporteur that he had been arrested on 13 July 1988, but had not been
held incommunicado, nor subjected to torture.
Islamic Republic of Iran
59. On 25 October 1988, a letter was addressed to the Government of the
Islamic Republic of Iran transmitting information alleging that torture was
systematically used in that country. According to reports, children as young
as six years old and women who had just given birth were subjected to
torture. Complaints were also transmitted regarding poor prison conditions
(narrow, damp, dark and overcrowded cells, insufficient food and non-existent
sanitary conditions). In addition, three cases of alleged torture while in
detention (Maryam Abdelahi, Maghrebi and Rashidi) were transmitted to the
Government.
Israel
60. On 3 October 1988, a letter was addressed to the Government of Israel
transmitting information alleging that the practice of torture on detainees,
in particular minors, had become a routine in the occupied territories.
Children and youths were subjected to beatings, sometimes until they lost
consciousness in Ansar II, Al-Far'a Prison, Gaza Central Prison and Ramallah
prison. Many children were reportedly tortured to extract confessions.
Torture was allegedly also carried out by the Israeli Defence Forces.
61. The Government of Israel transmitted a reply to the letter of 3 October
on 24 November 1988, repudiating the allegation that a policy of torture and
ill-treatment was practised in the administered territories. It stated that
Israel had been confronted with continual outbreaks of violence and that it
was Israel's responsibility, recognized by international law, to protect its
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents