A/64/215
42. Moreover, in many countries pretrial detainees are held together with
convicted prisoners, and prison guards, prosecutors and judges treat them as
criminals, in flagrant violation of the right of accused persons to be presumed
innocent until convicted by a competent, impartial and independent court. The
Special Rapporteur has interviewed many detainees who did not know whether they
had already been sentenced or not. The prison guards did not know either. It simply
does not matter, as the decision of the prosecutor to charge persons for a crime and
send them to pretrial detention is already widely regarded as a “sentence”. After
pretrial detainees have spent several years in pretrial detention without access to a
lawyer or a court, judges may finally sentence them to imprisonment simply to
justify the time they have already spent in police custody and pretrial detention. 3
43. The Special Rapporteur notes that one of his more surprising observations
from his fact-finding missions to many countries in different regions of the world is
that police and prison authorities simply do not regard it as their responsibility to
provide detainees with the most basic services necessary for survival, let alone for a
dignified existence or what human rights instruments call an “adequate standard of
living”, i.e., food, water, clothing, a toilet and a proper place to sleep. A few
examples from fact finding missions by the Special Rapporteur illustrate this point.
In Equatorial Guinea, detainees spend several weeks or even months in
overcrowded, often dark and filthy police cells with virtually nothing but a concrete
floor where they are kept for 24 hours a day. It is the task of their families to bring
them water in plastic bottles and food in plastic bags. Since there are no toilets, they
must use the same bottles to urinate and the plastic bags to defecate. In most police
stations, including the police headquarters in Malabo, plenty of filled and stinking
plastic bottles and bags had been thrown through the bars to the corridors and open
yards. Some cells were so overcrowded that there was no space for everyone to
sleep at the same time. Sleeping in shifts owing to a lack of space is common in
many of the police stations and pretrial detention facilities the Special Rapporteur
visited, including in Georgia, Nepal, Sri Lanka, Togo and the Transnistrian region of
the Republic of Moldova. In Indonesia and Paraguay, detainees are not only
deprived of basic services, such as food and medicine; in some cases, they even
have to pay a daily fee for the very fact that they are “accommodated” in a cell. If
detainees are poor or have no families in the vicinity to provide them with food or
money, they depend on richer detainees who might demand slavery-like services in
exchange.
44. In the police headquarters of Lagos, Nigeria, the Special Rapporteur found
more than 100 detainees, including women and children, in the so-called “torture
room” of the Criminal Investigation Department, where they were routinely
subjected to severe methods of torture in the presence of other detainees, including
gunshots into their legs from a short distance, and then left with serious injuries
without any medical treatment. According to the judgement of the forensic doctor
who accompanied the Special Rapporteur, some of the victims were going to die
unless their legs were immediately amputated. In Mongolia, long-term prisoners are
kept in strict solitary confinement for up to 30 years, and most of those interviewed
by the Special Rapporteur in these maximum security cells were in a state of mind
that no longer allowed for any meaningful interaction. Prisoners sentenced to death
__________________
3
10
See, for example, A/HRC/7/3/Add.4, paras. 51 and 52; see also reports of the Working Group on
Arbitrary Detention, for example, E/CN.4/2004/3, para. 75, and A/HRC/4/40, paras. 68 and 69.
09-43792
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents