CAT/C/46/2
the Convention extends this obligation, providing that, “Each State Party shall undertake to
prevent in any territory under its jurisdiction other acts of cruel, inhuman or degrading
treatment of punishment which do not amount to torture…”. As explained by the
Committee against Torture in its general comment No. 2, “article 2, paragraph 1, obliges
each State party to take actions that will reinforce the prohibition against torture”.5 Whilst
the obligation to prevent torture and ill-treatment buttresses the prohibition of torture, it
also remains an obligation in its own right and a failure to take appropriate preventive
measures which were within its power could engage the international responsibility of the
State, should torture occur in circumstances where the State would not otherwise have been
responsible.
104. Drawing attention to article 2 of the Convention, the International Court of Justice
has observed that “the content of the duty to prevent varies from one instrument to another,
according to the wording of the relevant provisions, and depending on the nature of the acts
to be prevented”.6 The Committee has said that the duty to prevent is “wide-ranging”7 and
has indicated that the content of that duty is not static since ‘the Committee’s understanding
of and recommendations in respect of effective measures are in a process of continual
evolution”8 and so are “not limited to those measures contained in the subsequent articles 3
to 16”.9
105. The Subcommittee on Prevention of Torture is of the view that, as these comments
suggest, it is not possible to devise a comprehensive statement of what the obligation to
prevent torture and ill-treatment entails in abstracto. It is of course both possible and
important to determine the extent to which a State has complied with its formal legal
commitments as set out in international instruments and which have a preventive impact but
whilst this is necessary it will rarely be sufficient to fulfil the preventive obligation: it is as
much the practice as it is the content of a State’s legislative, administrative, judicial or other
measures which lies at the heart of the preventive endeavour. Moreover, there is more to the
prevention of torture and ill-treatment than compliance with legal commitments. In this
sense, the prevention of torture and ill-treatment embraces — or should embrace — as
many as possible of those things which in a given situation can contribute towards the
lessening of the likelihood or risk of torture or ill-treatment occurring. Such an approach
requires not only that there be compliance with relevant international obligations and
standards in both form and substance but that attention is also paid to the whole range of
other factors which bear upon the experience and treatment of persons deprived of their
liberty and which by their very nature will be context specific.
106. It is for this reason that the Optional Protocol seeks to strengthen the protection of
persons deprived of their liberty, not by setting out additional substantive preventive
obligations but in contributing to the prevention of torture by establishing, at both the
international and national levels, a preventive system of regular visits and the drawing up of
reports and recommendations based thereon. The purpose of such reports and
recommendations is not only to bring about compliance with international obligations and
standards but to offer practical advice and suggestions as to how to reduce the likelihood or
risk of torture or ill-treatment occurring and will be firmly based on, and informed by, the
facts found and circumstances encountered during the visits undertaken. As a result, the
Subcommittee is of the view that it is best able to contribute to prevention by expanding on
5
6
7
8
9
GE.11-40683
CAT/C/GC/2, para 2.
Application of the Convention on the Prevention and Punishment of the Crime of Genocide (Bosnia
and Herzegovina v Serbia and Montenegro), Merits, Judgment of 26 February 2007, para. 429.
CAT/C/GC/2, para. 3.
Ibid., para. 4.
Ibid., para. 1.
21
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents