Malta
Netherlands
Poland
Portugal
Romania
Slovak Republic
Slovenia
Spain
Sweden
Switzerland13
United Kingdom
National legislation does not specify which coercive measures
are allowed; those in use are: body cuffs, metal handcuffs,
plastic handcuffs, head protection
From 1 January 2013, the allowed coercive measures are not
specified. Nonetheless, those in use are: metal handcuffs,
velcro straps, bite/spit mask, French body cuffs
Information not available
Handcuffs, French body cuffs, metal handcuffs, plastic
handcuffs, velcro straps (metal handcuffs are not allowed)
French body cuffs, plastic handcuffs, velcro straps, metal
handcuffs
Information not available
Standard measures used by the Slovenian police: handcuffs,
body cuffs, plastic handcuffs, straps. Measures that might be
used by the Slovenian police (only in case of unavailability of
the standard ones): adhesive tape, belt, straps. Measures used
during forced returns: American body cuffs (body cuff with
metallic parts), French body cuffs (in velcro), plastic
handcuffs
Velcro straps, metal handcuffs, body cuffs, head protection
Handcuffs. Other measures such as body cuffs, stretchers and
hoods, are not explicitly mentioned but admitted
During the flight phase: handcuffs NOT in metal (plastic,
velcro, laces…), batons. During the transport to the airport
metal handcuffs are also used. Returnees may also be tied to
wheelchairs if circumstances justify it
Information not available
The use of coercive measures, as reported by the authorities of the Member States that
participated in the research, must be in compliance with human rights, although the critical
aspects implied by the use of handcuffs or other permitted coercive measures are subject to the
specific attention of monitors. Indeed, recommendations are constantly made on this issue by
the bodies responsible for monitoring forced returns in Europe.
In Switzerland, for example, in the two-year period 2018-2019, the police withheld from the
employment of coercive measures in 48% of cases during transport to the airport. However, it
is noted that the use of these measures remains a widespread practice.
Also in the UK, the use of coercive measures is cause for concern. During the international
transfer phases the escort staff often uses a waist restraint belt that can be used in “restricted”
or in “secure” modality. In this second case, the person to be repatriated cannot move their
arms. The use of these measures is allowed only if “reasonable, proportionate and necessary”.
Although the use of these measures is allowed only if “reasonable, proportionate and
necessary”, the UK monitor has highlighted the over-use and prolonged duration of these
measures employed also with returnees who do not oppose resistance.
The same happens in Spain, where the Defensor del Pueblo has suggested the Police create a
logbook to track the use of coercive measures in airport premises, so as to allow verification of
the use of these tools during return operations. Returnees usually wear textile ties which are
13
Not a EU Member State but a Schengen country.
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents