widespread and systematic torture and murder to obtain control of the
government and, having done so, to maintain control of government by
those means for so long as might be necessary. Or it may be used in
totalitarian states as a means of extracting confessions from individuals
whom the authorities wish to put on trial so that they can be used against
them in evidence.
103. The examples I have just mentioned are of torture as an
instrument of power. But the use of torture to obtain confessions was
also sanctioned by the judiciary in many civil law jurisdictions, and it
remained part of their criminal procedure until the latter part of the 17th
century. This was never part of English criminal procedure and, as there
was no need for it, its use for this purpose was prohibited by the
common law. But warrants for the use of torture were issued from time
to time by the Privy Council against prisoners in the Tower under the
Royal Prerogative. Four hundred years ago, on 4 November 1605, Guy
Fawkes was arrested when he was preparing to blow up the Parliament
which was to be opened the next day, together with the King and all the
others assembled there. Two days later James I sent orders to the Tower
authorising torture to be used to persuade Fawkes to confess and reveal
the names of his co-conspirators. His letter stated that “the gentler
tortours” were first to be used on him, and that his torturers were then to
proceed to the worst until the information was extracted out of him. On
9 November 1605 he signed his confession with a signature that was
barely legible and gave the names of his fellow conspirators. On
27 January 1606 he and seven others were tried before a special
commission in Westminster Hall. Signed statements in which they had
each confessed to treason were shown to them at the trial, acknowledged
by them to be their own and then read to the jury: Carswell, Trial of Guy
Fawkes (1934), pp 90-92.
104. This practice came to an end in 1640 when the Act of 16
Charles I, c 10, abolished the Star Chamber. The jurisdiction of the
Privy Council in all matters affecting the liberty of the subject was
transferred to the ordinary courts, which until then in matters of State
the executive could by-pass. Torture continued to be used in Scotland
on the authority of the Privy Council until the end of the 17th century,
but the practice was brought to an end there after the Union by section 5
of the Treason Act 1708. That section, which remains in force subject
only to one minor amendment (see Statute Law (Repeals) Act 1977, Sch
I, Part IV) and applies to England as well as Scotland, declares that no
person accused of any crime can be put to torture.
-60-
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents