European legal and policy framework on immigration detention of children
For example, in Austria, a legal adviser must advise and
support a detained person, who may be a child.261 The
adviser is entitled to participate at all stages of proceedings. In Belgium, all persons placed in detention,
including children, should meet with a social worker
upon arrival, who provides information on the detention
facility and the person’s rights and obligations, including the right to appeal. Similarly in Poland, dedicated
staff, namely a return assistant (opiekun powrotowy)
and a social assistant (opiekun socjalny), must inform
all detainees, including children, of the detention decision including the right to appeal.262 The social assistant is a Border Guard officer or staff member trained
in intercultural communication whose task is to inform
detained foreigners individually about their rights and
to identify persons in need of special treatment.263 The
return assistant is a Border Guard officer or worker
responsible for individually informing detained foreigners about the detention decisions and the administrative procedures in place.264 Nevertheless, there is
no evidence that these persons receive child-specific
training.
Some Member States include specific measures and/
or practices for informing children in their return
procedures.
Unaccompanied children’s legal guardian or
representative should inform them about their rights
and obligations. In principle, the guardian should also
inform the child about complaints procedure and support him or her to submit complaints about the detention conditions and/or other violations of their rights
when detained. However, often guardians are not
appointed swiftly upon deprivation of liberty, FRA has
found. When appointed, often guardians have no or limited personal contact with the child: they do not meet
the child in person or visit the detention facility.265
Article 20 of the CRC enshrines states’ obligation to
protect children who are temporarily or permanently
deprived of their family environment, entitling these
children to special protection and assistance. Every
child deprived of parental care, including unaccompanied children, should have a guardian appointed.270 The
guardian exercises three core functions: (1) they ensure
the child’s overall well-being, (2) they safeguard the
child’s best interests and (3) they exercise legal representation, complementing the limited legal capacity of the child, when necessary, in the same way that
parents do.271
261 Austria, Bundesgesetz, mit dem die allgemeinen
Bestimmungen über das Verfahren vor dem Bundesamt
für Fremdenwesen und Asyl zur Gewährung von
internationalem Schutz, Erteilung von Aufenthaltstiteln aus
berücksichtigungswürdigen Gründen, Abschiebung, Duldung
und zur Erlassung von aufenthaltsbeendenden Maßnahmen
sowie zur Ausstellung von österreichischen Dokumenten für
Fremde geregelt werden (BFA-Verfahrensgesetz – BFA-VG),
BGBl. I Nr. 87/2012, Article 51.
262 Poland, Headquaters of Border Guard (Komenda Główna
Straży Granicznej), Reply to Helsinki Foundation for Human
Rights to the request for disclosure of public records,
11 March 2016, KG-OI-III.0180.19.2016.JB-I.
263 Poland, The Border Guard (Straż Graniczna),
17 September 2015, Rules of conduct of Border Guard
with foreigners in need of special treatment (Zasady
postępowania Straży Granicznej z cudzoziemcami
wymagającymi szczególnego traktowania).
264 Poland, Headquaters of Border Guard (Komenda Główna
Straży Granicznej), Reply to Helsinki Foundation for Human
Rights to the request for disclosure of public records,
11 March 2016, KG-OI-III.0180.19.2016.JB-I.
265 FRA (2014), Guardianship for children deprived of parental
care – A handbook to reinforce guardianship systems to
cater for the specific needs of child victims of trafficking,
Luxembourg, Publications Office, p. 69.
66
• In the Netherlands, the Repatriation and Departure
Service (Dienst Terugkeer en Vertrek) has officials
trained in communicating with unaccompanied children. In the case of families, parents are supposed
to communicate the decision to the children.266
• The United Kingdom sets up a Family Departure
Meeting in cases of forced return. 267 This takes
place in the family home. Children are encouraged
to attend. With the permission of the parents, the
Home Office official (Family Engagement Manager)
must speak to the children directly to ensure that
they understand the potential impact of arrest on
the family.268 These officers have specialised training from the Home Office.269
6.2. Guardianship and legal
representation
In practice, responsibility for representing the child in
particular administrative proceedings might be separate
from the other two functions of guardianship. Legal
representatives, unlike guardians, have a restricted
mandate in national law: to represent the child in particular proceedings.
266 The Netherlands, Ministry for Security and Justice
(Ministerie van Veiligheid en justitie).
267 United Kingdom, UK Visas and Immigration (2013)
Enforcement instructions and guidance, 10 December 2013,
Chapter 45 (b), para.��2.5.1.
268 Ibid, para. 3.
269 United Kingdom, Home Office, Evaluation of the New Family
Returns Process research report 78, December 2013, p. 33
Footnote 65.
270 UN, Committee on the Rights of the Child, General Comment
No. 6 (2005): Treatment of Unaccompanied and Separated
Children Outside their Country of Origin, 1 September 2005,
CRC/GC/2005/6, para. 21.
271 FRA (2014), Guardianship for children deprived of parental
care – A handbook to reinforce guardianship systems to
cater for the specific needs of child victims of trafficking,
Luxembourg, Publications Office, pp. 15 and 37.
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents