37
iii) prisoners with personality disorders
68.
Among the patients of a prison health care service there is always a certain proportion
of unbalanced, marginal individuals who have a history of family traumas, long-standing drug
addiction, conflicts with authority or other social misfortunes. They may be violent, suicidal or
characterised by unacceptable sexual behaviour, and are for most of the time incapable of
controlling or caring for themselves.
69.
The needs of these prisoners are not truly medical, but the prison doctor can promote
the development of socio-therapeutic programmes for them, in prison units which are organised
along community lines and carefully supervised.
Such units can reduce the prisoners' humiliation, self-contempt and hatred, give them
a sense of responsibility and prepare them for reintegration. Another direct advantage of
programmes of this type is that they involve the active participation and commitment of the
prison staff.
iv) prisoners unsuited for continued detention
70.
Typical examples of this kind of prisoner are those who are the subject of a short-term
fatal prognosis, who are suffering from a serious disease which cannot be properly treated in
prison conditions, who are severely handicapped or of advanced age. The continued detention of
such persons in a prison environment can create an intolerable situation. In cases of this type, it
lies with the prison doctor to draw up a report for the responsible authority, with a view to
suitable alternative arrangements being made.
f.
Professional independence
71.
The health-care staff in any prison is potentially a staff at risk. Their duty to care for
their patients (sick prisoners) may often enter into conflict with considerations of prison
management and security. This can give rise to difficult ethical questions and choices. In order
to guarantee their independence in health-care matters, the CPT considers it important that such
personnel should be aligned as closely as possible with the mainstream of health-care provision
in the community at large.
72.
Whatever the formal position under which a prison doctor carries on his activity, his
clinical decisions should be governed only by medical criteria.
The quality and the effectiveness of medical work should be assessed by a qualified
medical authority. Likewise, the available resources should be managed by such an authority,
not by bodies responsible for security or administration.
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents