CAT/OP/PRT/1
the court was closed and the arrested person had to remain in detention until Monday to be
taken before a judge.
63.
The Subcommittee notes allegations by prisoners interviewed concerning a lack of
access to a lawyer during their initial police detention. Some prisoners alleged that they had
not received information on the right to contact a lawyer. Others argued that they had met
an ex officio lawyer for the first time in court and that the lawyer had not been adequately
prepared. At the same time, the Subcommittee observed that the arrest records at police
stations visited by the delegation had been thoroughly compiled and included a page listing
the rights of individuals during arrest signed by the arrested person. The list of rights was
available in several languages. The delegation also had the opportunity to look into the
police database, where the status and location of the arrested person could be tracked in real
time.
64.
The Subcommittee recommends that the State party ensure the access of
detained persons to a lawyer immediately after their arrest and that it at least secure
the presence of legal counsel during interrogation. The State party should also extend
and strengthen the system of free legal aid to ensure effective and quality
representation for all detained persons, on an equal basis.
B.
Material conditions of detention at police stations
65.
The delegation found that the material conditions in the police stations visited were
satisfactory for a short-term detention. The detention cells were around 8 m2, with an
inbuilt bench and a toilet. Mattresses and blankets were provided. Arrested persons
received three meals a day. The delegation noted that the natural light was poor and the
artificial lighting very dim. The police stations visited did not have a yard for the detainees
to take exercise.
66.
The Subcommittee recommends that the State party ensure that the lighting in
the police detention cells is sufficient for reading and that persons arrested for more
than 24 hours have the possibility to spend at least one hour outside of the cell in the
open air.
VI. Prisons
A.
Material conditions of detention in prisons
67.
In all prisons the Subcommittee delegation heard complaints about lack of work,
study, rehabilitation and recreational opportunities and difficulties in contacting the
professionals engaged by the system to take care of such tasks, namely the educators. In
some cases, in high security cells newspapers were reportedly not allowed and books were
almost impossible to get. Many inmates complained that work opportunities were poorly
remunerated. Some inmates said that those who were offered work activities were often
encouraged to report on other prisoners. At the same time, the delegation noted a positive
practice in Sintra Prison, where about half of prisoners worked, including outside of the
facility.
68. The Subcommittee recommends the State party to broaden the work, education,
rehabilitation and recreational opportunities for prisoners. Such opportunities
facilitate rehabilitation of prisoners and their future reintegration in society. The
Subcommittee also recommends that fairly remunerated work opportunities be made
available to all detainees. The State party might consider dividing working hours
between several prisoners to allow more people to be engaged in purposeful activities.
69.
In all prisons, without exception, inmates complained about the quality, quantity and
variety of food and in some cases also food hygiene. Complaints ranged from food smelling
rotten or being too greasy to reports of foreign bodies such as cockroaches and other insects
in the food served. Inmates also complained about the overly strict regulations as to what
food their families were allowed to bring for them, with basic items being prohibited. The
12
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents