JUSTICE FOR ALL
2.6.8. TREATMENT
2.6.8.1. ADEQUACY OF TREATMENT
The research has revealed that adequate and
evidence-based psychosocial and/or psychiatric treatment, based on free and informed
consent, is rarely offered to detainees with
intellectual and/or psychosocial disabilities,
whether they are detained in an ordinary
prison, special prison units or (forensic)
psychiatric institutions. For detainees in
pre-trial detention, such treatment is often
non-existent.
Generally, when it comes to prisons, all
partner countries follow some form of admission procedure that includes the medical
assessment of any health needs, including a
psychological assessment of mental health
needs. However, most prisons do not offer
sufficient psychiatric or psychotherapeutic
services and there is a lack of qualified staff
(see Section 2.6.6). A lack of continuous care
and treatment options while serving a prison
sentence can lead to a deterioration of health
conditions and the isolation of the persons
concerned. Individuals with intellectual and/or
psychosocial disabilities may struggle to adapt
to the prison environment and participate in
programs. Research in Germany has shown
that if a transfer to a psychiatric department,
within or outside the correctional system, is
not possible, detainees with intellectual and/
or psychosocial disabilities who demonstrate
specific needs may be moved to observation
and/or highly secured cells, thus isolating
them from other detainees. Particularly,
individuals whose disability has not been
diagnosed may be perceived as "troublemakers" and are more likely to face security and
disciplinary measures, often being isolated.
Due to a lack of alternatives, individuals with
psychotic disorders, self-harm tendencies and
suicidal thoughts may be housed in these
conditions for months. However, their health
condition usually does not improve with this
type of isolated placement. The correctional
system is often unable to provide the necessary medical and psychological treatment,
close supervision and hygiene standards.
Consequently, the persons concerned end
up living in deplorable conditions, contribut-
ing significantly to the deterioration of their
health. Furthermore, due to their health
status, further measures such as privileges
and releases are often discontinued.249
Although (forensic) psychiatric institutions
embody the express purpose of providing
treatment, the research has shown that the
availability and quality of psychiatric treatment
is lacking in many countries. In Germany, on
average, only 30% of the detainees in preventive detention are in therapy, although the
proportion of persons affected with mental
health conditions requiring treatment is
significantly higher at 79.3%.250
In Austria, multiple experts from different
fields (including representatives of NPMs,
lawyers, medical doctors and probation
officers) have pointed out that persons who
are subjected to preventive detention very
often do not receive the necessary treatment
and support they need. There have been multiple accounts of persons not receiving the
treatment (particularly therapeutic treatment)
they need for multiple months.251
A lack of adequate treatment is not simply
problematic because it can lead to deterioration of a person’s mental and physical
wellbeing, but also because it can have
repercussions on the length of detention.
Successful treatment – and improvement
of a person’s condition – are often linked
to conditional release prospects. In Austria,
persons who are subjected to preventive detention are often detained in ordinary prisons
(or specialised departments within ordinary
prisons) that simply do not offer the treatment/therapy that is necessary, impacting the
possibilities for conditional release – which is
often dependent on a demonstration of active participation in therapeutic services and
improvement of one’s condition – and leading
to overlong stays in preventive detention.252
A lack of adequate treatment is especially
prevalent for persons in pre-trial detention,
where services are generally even scarcer and
there are generally no special regimes in place
to ensure the provision of treatment and special medical care for persons with intellectual
and/or psychosocial disabilities in ordinary
69
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents