Advocating for a better policy
environment
While at the forefront of expertise on the Istanbul
Protocol and its use in the prevention of torture,
another aspect of the IRCT’s work on this field is to
ensure the best possible policy environment.
The advocacy towards the UN human rights mechanisms, especially the UN Committee against Torture,
the UN Subcommittee on Prevention of Torture and
the Universal Periodic Review (UPR), holds great
potential of promoting medical documentation and
the application of the Istanbul Protocol as a standard
in countries around the world. Using the UN system as
a platform to promote implementation of anti-torture
measures, although a long-term advocacy activity,
provides a greater impact. Through the specific
data and information gained in the examination of
victims and documentation of torture, human rights
mechanism can be provided with the much needed
case examples and solid facts on this situation for
assessing state compliance with international obligations in preventing torture.
In November 2010, a team of experts comprising
two staff of the IRCT Secretariat and a psychological expert from an IRCT member centre briefed the
UN Committee against Torture on the importance of
using medical reports based on the Istanbul Protocol.
Throughout the work of the Committee in the past
years, it can be seen that it is increasing its initiative to promote the implementation of the Istanbul
Protocol on a broader scale. For example, the Committee’s concluding remarks of the third periodic reports
of Turkey and Ecuador in November 2010 refer several
times to the importance of the Istanbul Protocol. They
acknowledge that a lack of independence for many
of the world’s medical doctors is a key obstacle to
combating impunity for perpetrators.
In working with the Subcommittee on Prevention of
Torture (SPT), the IRCT is aiming at supporting the
Subcommittee to address a number of obstacles to
an effective application of standardised forensic
medical evaluations of torture victims in detention.
These relate especially to the independence and
competence of the persons who conduct these in the
context of persons deprived of their liberty.
The regional mechanisms, especially in Europe, Africa
and Latin America, also play a central role in ensuring
that cases of torture victims are taken seriously. They
also play a central role in ensuring that the right structures and funding are in place to hold perpetrators
accountable and provide torture victims with redress
and reparations – including as full rehabilitation as
We are very encouraged by the engaged involvement of the Committee
against Torture in implementation of the Istanbul Protocol, which
is clearly illustrated by the high number of constructive questions
and comments made during the sessions and in the concluding
observations. We hope that we can keep an ongoing dialogue with the
Committee on ensuring that forensic medical evidence of torture is
more effectively used in the countries they review to prove allegations
of torture to the benefit of torture victims around the world.
18
— Miriam Reventlow, IRCT Head of Legal and Advocacy
International Rehabilitation Council for Torture Victims
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents