Operation of the National Preventive Mechanism within the Office...
1. Operation of the National Preventive Mechanism within the
Office of the Human Rights Defender
On 14 October 2010, the National Preventive Mechanism Department was set up as
a result of a reorganisation of the Office. Since January 2011, it has had eight employees
with a background in law, education, resocialisation, and politology specialising in resocialisation and criminology. Insufficient staff of the Department did not allow for carrying
out all the NPM visits scheduled for 2011, such visits were also performed by Criminal
Law Department staff, as needed. The National Preventive Mechanism Department was
also supported by personnel of the Offices of Local Representatives in Gdańsk, Wrocław
and Katowice. All members of the National Preventive Mechanism Department and all
employees of Offices of Local Representatives of the Human Rights Defender act by virtue
of law, authorised by the Defender and on her behalf.5 The NPM personnel exercises the
Defender’s competence, and their actions are considered actions of the Defender herself.
Taking into account all aspects of detention, NPM visits require a multidisciplinary
approach. In order to properly check the way in which the detainees are treated, it is necessary to obtain information from a number of sources. It is required, inter alia, to analyse
medical records, talk to mentally disturbed patients and evaluate the access of detainees
to medical care at the place of detention. Performing the above in a reliable way would be
impossible without substantive support and expertise. Yet due to limited funds, experts
participated only in 35 visits from the time when the National Preventive Mechanism was
set up. In reality, participation of specialists, physicians in particular, should be ensured
during each and every preventive visit under the Mechanism.
2. Financing
The National Preventive Mechanism Department is an organisational unit of the Defender’s Office. The Defender’s expenses are covered by the State budget, with the Defender
being the fund administrator. In 2011, the Sejm cut the budget of the Office of the Human
Rights Defender from the planned PLN 36,477,000 to PLN 35,424,000. This cut resulted in
a reduced budget for the National Preventive Mechanism from the planned PLN 1,740,000
to PLN 1,265,000. Thus, the tasks of NPM were performed at the expense of other activities of the Defender, and were largely limited. This constituted a breach of Article 18(3)
and (4) of the OPCAT. The situation is expected to improve in 2012 as the Human Rights
Defender will, in all probability, be granted additional funds for running the National Preventive Mechanism (Article 24(3)(3) of the Act of 22 December 2011 amending the Acts
5
See Article 20(1) of the Act on the Human Rights Defender (Dz. U. of 2001, No 14, item 147, as amended) and § 4 of the Statute
of the Office of the Human Rights Defender.
13
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents