A/HRC/31/57/Add.2
suspended sentences, and conditional discharge – as a matter of urgency to reduce
overcrowding in prisons and facilitate inmates’ reintegration into society.
23.
The Special Rapporteur welcomes the recent development of the “Ghana Sentencing
Guidelines” and hopes that despite their non-binding nature, the Guidelines will promote
greater consistency, remedy undue harshness and inequities in sentencing, and encourage
more reasonable use of judicial discretion. The imposition of long sentences for non-violent
offenses, such as a minimum of five and ten years’ imprisonment for the use and possession
of narcotic drugs, respectively, under the Narcotic Drugs (Control, Enforcement and
Sanctions) Act 1990, is troubling and contributes significantly to prison overcrowding (with
90% of remand detainees in some cases reportedly convicted of possession or consumption
of ‘Indian hemp’). The Government reports that the Act is under review, with plans to
provide for classifications and consideration of amounts in determining the purpose of
possession. Such a review would be an encouraging development. Mandatory minimum
sentences for lesser, non-violent offences should be reduced or eliminated, and time spent
on remand should be taken into account in sentencing. Greater reliance on alternative
dispute resolution measures also has the potential to help unburden the encumbered
criminal justice system.
24.
The Special Rapporteur welcomes reports that President Mahama granted amnesty
to 2,004 prisoners in 2014 and 2015, but is concerned by claims of discrimination and
corruption in this process. Recalling that post-sentencing disposals are not an optimal
solution for reducing overcrowding in prisons, he urges the Government to extend
eligibility for remission, commutation of sentences, parole, or pardon to inmates serving
long sentences, additional to those on death row and serving life sentences. While the
President recently called on the Director-General of the GPS to present a proposal for the
remission of sentences for prisoners who have demonstrated good behavior and for elderly
and sick inmates, a review of non-violent offenses for which bail is not available has not
occurred despite its potential to help reduce the number of remand prisoners. Parole
remains unavailable despite its contemplation by the Constitution and despite the
Government’s indication that it seeks to establish parole boards and introduce measures to
grant parole to prisoners with good chances of reintegration and solid social support
networks. Such measures, if and when implemented, must be backed with appropriate
levels of support and staff training.
Right to Counsel and Legal Aid
25.
The right to counsel is guaranteed in the Constitution and a fundamental safeguard
against torture and other ill-treatment. However, it is not effectively implemented in
practice as the vast majority of Ghanaians in the criminal justice system are indigent and
remain unable to exercise this right to access a lawyer, let alone from the moment of
apprehension and at all stages of the investigation process. The Ministry of Justice reports
that 90% of defendants in cases heard by the high courts benefit from assistance of counsel,
which is required for first-degree felonies at the high court level; however, this is not a
sufficient guarantee for the vast majority of defendants, whose cases are adjudicated only
by district or circuit courts.
26.
The Legal Aid Scheme of 1997 (Act 542) provides the right to legal assistance to
persons charged with capital offenses punishable by death or a life sentence. The scheme
should be expanded to cover all criminal offenses. Although it aspires to provide free legal
assistance to indigent defendants, this is not a requirement mandated in legislation. The
Scheme became independent from the Ministry of Justice and retained control over its
budget pursuant to a Constitutional Review Commission decision in 2012, but continues to
be woefully underfunded and understaffed, despite an increase in staff from 40 to 70. There
are currently only 16 public defenders comprising the Legal Aid Scheme, divided amongst
8
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents