Compendium of Standards, Good Practices and Recommendations
Country
Procedure
Duration
Denmark
An application is submitted to the
Administration for Conscientious Objection,
where the applicant signs to confirm that
military duty is irreconcilable with their
conscience. They then choose an institution
where alternative service can be fulfilled.
Equal length to military service
Estonia
Conscripts can apply to the Defence
Recourses Agency, stating clear reasons for
alternative service. The Agency will assess
the reasoning of the application and has the
right to inquire with the conscript’s referred
religious organization, place of work or
educational institution.
12 months, compared to military
service of between 8 and 11
months314
Conscientious objection for members of regular armed forces
While most OSCE participating States recognize that conscientious objection applies to
conscripts, fewer countries recognize the right in the case of professional service personnel.
Those that do include the Czech Republic, Germany, Slovenia and Switzerland.315
The UN OHCHR has pointed out that:
“The application of the right to conscientious objection to persons who
voluntarily serve in the armed forces is based on the view that an individual’s
deeply held convictions can evolve and that individuals voluntarily serving
in armed forces may over time develop conscientious objection to bearing
arms.”316
In April 2006, PACE called on member states:
“to introduce into their legislation the right to be registered as a conscientious
objector at any time, namely before, during or after military service, as well
as the right of career servicemen to be granted the status of conscientious
objector”.317
314
“Compulsory Military Service”, Estonian Defence Forces website, http://www.mil.ee/en/defence-forces/
compulsory-military-service.
315
Responses to the ODIHR-DCAF 2018 questionnaire.
316
UN ECOSOC, OHCHR report 2004, op. cit., note 310, para. 26.
317
PACE, Recommendation 1742, op. cit., note 294, para. 9.7.
139
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents