CAT/OP/PER/1/Add.1
3.3
Juvenile detention centres
3.3.1
General issues
89. In paragraph 88 of the Subcommittee’s report, it is recommended that the
Code on Children and Adolescents, 70 and particularly Legislative Decree No. 990
(2007), be harmonized with international standards, according to which deprivation
of liberty for children and adolescents should be used as a measure of last resort.
90. Some of the provisions contained in Legislative Decree No. 990 71 were
abolished or amended through Legislative Decree No. 1204, which amends the Code
on Children and Adolescents in order to establish and regulate the imposition of
penalties on juvenile offenders. 72
91. Thus, in contrast to what had been established in Legislative Decree No. 990
with regard to the detainment of adolescents, Legislative Decree No. 1204 provides
that a custodial sentence is an exceptional measure and is applied as a last resort. It
also includes provisions to regulate the imposition of penalties for juvenile
offenders.
92. Subsequently, the Code of Criminal Responsibility for Adolescents was
adopted through Legislative Decree No. 1348, 73 with the purpose of amending the
legislation related to the treatment of adolescents in conflict with the law. The
Decree established the Permanent Multisectoral Commission for the Implementation
of the Code of Criminal Responsibility for Adolescents, with responsibility for its
implementation.
93. This provision incorporates, inter alia, the principle of the best interests of the
child, the pro adolescent principle, the educational principle, the principle of
specialized justice and the principle of diversion (use of non -judicial measures) or
minimum intervention.
94. In turn, it establishes that adolescents between 14 and 17 years of age are
responsible for the commission of an offence on the basis of special criminal
responsibility, taking into account their age and personal characteristics . 74
95. In this regard, the rights of the adolescent should be comprehensively and
simultaneously safeguarded during the process of criminal r esponsibility, and the
development and exercise of their rights should be considered as guiding principles
and should not be compromised by a negative interpretation of the best interests of
the adolescent. 75
96. It also provides that the interpretation and app lication of the Code should take
into account all the rights and guarantees recognized by the Political Constitution of
Peru and in the special laws on the subject, the United Nations Convention on the
Rights of the Child and other international instrument s in force and ratified by Peru,
as well as in international standards in the field of juvenile criminal justice . 76
97. In view of the above, it was determined that the deprivation of liberty of
adolescents, even when preventive, is an exceptional measure and must be duly
substantiated as it is a measure of last resort. The rationale for the measure must
__________________
70
71
72
73
74
75
76
V.17-05867
jurisdiccional-de-las-salas-penales-permanente-y-tr-acuerdo-pleno-jurisdiccional-de-las-penalaspermanente-1395131-1/
Congress of the Republic, Act No. 27337 adopting the New Code on Adolescen ts, El Peruano
(Official Gazette) (7 August 2000).
Executive branch of government, Legislative Decree No. 1204 amending the Code on Children
and Adolescents in order to establish and regulate the imposition of penalties for juvenile
offenders, El Peruano (Official Gazette) (23 September 2015).
Judiciary, Official Letter No. 2215-2016-SG-CS-PJ of 28 March 2016, p. 5.
Executive branch of government, Legislative Decree No. 1348 adopting the Code of Criminal
Responsibility for Adolescents, El Peruano (Official Gazette) (7 January 2017).
Article I of the Preliminary Title of Legislative Decree No. 1348.
Article II of the Preliminary Title of Legislative Decree No. 1348.
Article XIV of the Preliminary Title of Legislative Decree No. 1348.
15/27
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents