Omega Research Foundation
operation. Electric shock was allegedly used against handcuffed detainees. Gloria Tobón was
reportedly doused in water before having electric shocks applied to her arms, breasts and
genitals.137
Bolivia: It is alleged that electric shock stun guns are one of the main means used by law
enforcement officials to inflict torture.138 Following his detention in August 2014, Michael
Ylimori Daza alleged he was tortured by law enforcement officers in an attempt to force him
to confess to murder. The Institute of Forensic Investigations stated his injuries were
consistent with his claims that an electric shock weapon had been used on him.139
Direct contact electric shock weapons are inherently prone to abuse as they permit the holder to cause
extreme pain to the victim at the touch of a button without leaving substantial marks. These weapons
are designed to enforce compliance through pain rather than incapacitation and they have no
legitimate law enforcement function which cannot be achieved through less harmful means.
Although projectile electric shock devices can be used for legitimate law enforcement purposes in
exceptional circumstances, their use should be strictly controlled and they should never be used as a
general force tool. They should never be used on those in vulnerable situations, particularly those in
mechanical restraints. The use of these weapons should be subject to the same reporting and
accountability requirements as the use of firearms. The effects of the use of all types of projectile
electric shock devices, regardless of voltage, must be independently evaluated.
Recommendations
Prohibit the manufacture, trade and use of direct contact electric shock weapons for law
enforcement purposes, including stun guns, stun batons and stun shields, and any type of
body-worn electric shock device, such as stun belts.
As a less lethal alternative to firearms, the deployment of projectile electric shock devices
should be subject to a similar standard to that which applies to the use of firearms. Their
lawful use should be limited to situations where officers are faced with an imminent threat of
death or serious (i.e. potentially life-threatening) injury to themselves or others which cannot
be contained by less extreme options.
Use of projectile electric shock devices in ‘drive stun’ mode poses a substantial risk of torture
or other cruel, inhuman and degrading treatment or punishment, and therefore should be
expressly forbidden. Only those weapons that record every mode of use should be permitted.
137
Amnesty International, Venezuela: Informe para el Comité Contra la Tortura de las Naciones Unidas,
October 2014, p. 17.
138
ACAT, A World of Torture, 2013, p. 40.
139
Sergio Mendoza, ‘IDIF certifica que Ylimori recibió golpes y descargas eléctricas,’ Página Siete, 27 August
2014, <http://www.paginasiete.bo/sociedad/2014/8/27/idif-certifica-ylimori-recibio-golpes-descargaselectricas-30546.html> [accessed 31 May 2016].
32
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents