National Preventive Mechanism
Use of net beds
prohibited as at 1
January 2015
In July 2014, taking into consideration the protection of human dignity
and the obligations of the Republic of Austria under international law, the
Federal Ministry of Health, as mutually agreed with the Federal Ministry of
Justice, issued a decree to all Governors that the use of psychiatric intensive
beds (net beds) as well as other “cage-type beds” no longer corresponds to
European standards and is therefore not permitted. In light of the necessary
concomitant measures, the operators of medical facilities and nursing and
group homes were given a one-year transition period until 1 July 2015,
based on the Hospitalisation of Mentally Ill Persons Act and the Nursing and
Residential Homes Residence Act.
Concomitant measures
necessary
In this regard the NPM wishes to emphasise that indeed a number of
concomitant measures are necessary during the transition period in order to
prevent net beds from simply being replaced by an increased use of mechanical
restraints. Only one approach that ensures that alternative solutions are
found to the greatest extent possible conforms to human rights principles. To
this end, it is unavoidable to increase de-escalation measures and to review
the current staff headcount. The Vienna Association of Hospitals has set up
a multi-disciplinary working group consisting of medical and non-medical
experts that is supposed to develop strategies for replacing net beds and drive
the implementation of these strategies forward.
As a reaction to this decree, the University Clinic for Psychiatry in Graz ceased
the use of net beds. The NPM will now carefully watch whether this decree
by the Federal Ministry of Health will be complied with in other facilities in
a timely manner.
¾¾ When the use of net beds is discontinued, alternatives to measures
restricting freedom must be considered and realised.
Private security companies
In accordance with observations made by the commissions, the NPM Report
2013 (pp. 39 et seq.) critically reflected that private security companies are
under contract and are part of the everyday operation of some psychiatric
medical facilities and are also used to help with patients. Such findings
were also made by the commissions in 2014; the justification for this is
frequently the lack of resources and the necessary protection of staff from
violence in psychiatric settings. Humane care and treatment of persons
suffering from psychiatric ailments is a highly sensitive area due to possible
intense intrusion into fundamental human rights. Nevertheless, possibilities
and limits of the use of private security companies’ services not only in the
protection of buildings but also in fields of activity that are normally staffed
94
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents