themselves next to a road in order to detect a few offenders, with a clear-up rate of 100%, the
latter always being identified.
The proportion of placements in police custody that continue for more than twenty four
hours28 as well as the length of police custody as a whole are relatively uniform. Excluding the
case of Montereau, the highest level is twice that of the lowest (ranging from 11% to 22%) and
divergence from the average is small. The average length of custody, which is relatively high,
especially when compared to the length of questioning, varies between a minimum of
12 hours 36 minutes and a maximum of 20 hours 38 minutes. In this case again, methods of
operation are as important as criminal activity itself in accounting for these differences.
Finally, the number of placements in police custody per day reflects considerable
differences in the activity of police stations, which are obviously dependent on data concerning
the population of the police district29, the volume of crime and the activity of the departments.
The highest level (11.2 per day at Metz) is ten times greater than the lowest (1.2 at Niort), which
naturally leads to very different workloads from one establishment to another, as well as different
workflow management. The workload of one police station may be temporarily increased,
because persons placed in police custody in other establishments are sent to it due lack of
personnel, above all at night.
Within the sharp contrasts of this overall picture, the conditions of exercise of
fundamental rights now need to be examined.
2.2.1.2 Data concerning Practical Details of Police Custody
For the purposes of clarity, the data is once again divided into two tables. They list about
fifteen items which the inspectors are careful to verify during each of their inspections. Once
again, the table is far from reflecting the reality of inspections30, but nevertheless gives an initial
idea of the practical details of police custody.
Amiens Angers Chartre Chessy Douai Metz
s
Montereau Niort
No. of
individual
cells
4
5
3
4
7
2
6
0
No. of
collective
cells
1
1
1
1
0
2
1
2
No. of cells
for minors
0
0
1
0
1
2
0
0
5
6
5
5
8
6
7
2
Total cells
28
National average: 17.3% en 2009 (excluding road traffic offences; though the latter seldom lead to extensions of
police custody); 18.2% in 2010.
29
The average population of the seventeen police districts studied comes to 94,900 inhabitants, for a range of between
31,943 (for Chessy) and 204,500 (for Douai).
30
For an exhaustive view refer to the inspection reports of police custody facilities published in their entirety on the
cglpl.fr website.
33
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents