Section three Strengthing the NPM
In total, NPM members carried out at least
1,580 inspections during the year and at
least 66,053 monitoring visits.
NPM self-assessment
NPM members conduct a self-assessment
each year using methodology based on the
SPT’s ‘analytical self-assessment tool for
NPMs’. The tool allows NPMs to examine
their effectiveness and efficiency.41 This is
the fifth year in which the self-assessment
has been carried out. Of the 21 NPM
members, 20 completed the self-assessment
and 80% of the assessments were peer
reviewed. The peer review process involves
NPM members sharing their responses with
one another to receive constructive external
review and ensure consistency of approach.
The self-assessment responses were
analysed in line with the three fundamental
NPM powers set out in OPCAT Article 19, to:
(a) examine the treatment of those deprived
of their liberty; (b) make recommendations
with the aim of improving their treatment
and conditions; and (c) submit comments on
existing and draft legislation. The following
table shows the compliance NPM members
reported with each of these powers.
General findings
Members reported full compliance with
84.3% of the self-assessment questions, a
slight decrease on the 86.5% compliance
reported in the previous year.42 Reported
non-compliance increased to 2% from 1.6%
in 2016–17. Further analysis shows that the
decrease in reported compliance is largely
due to additional members reporting this
year than in the previous two years. Given
the difference in members reporting across
years, the year-on-year results should not
be considered comparable. Rather, the
results this year are likely to provide a more
accurate picture of compliance.
41
The UK NPM’s self-assessment questionnaire can be found in Appendix 8 of the Fifth Annual Report, available at https://
s3-eu-west-2.amazonaws.com/npm-prod-storage-19n0nag2nk8xk/uploads/2015/05/NPM-5th-Annual-Report-2013-14.
pdf, accessed 21 November 2018. A full write-up of the self-assessment methodology is available at https://s3-eu-west-2.
amazonaws.com/npm-prod-storage-19n0nag2nk8xk/uploads/2015/08/UK-NPM-self-assessment-write-up.pdf, accessed
21 November 2018.
42
The percentages reported in this section are calculated using the responses provided by the 20 members that completed
the self-assessment (rather than the 21 total members).
35
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents