Chapter 7 — Programme Structure and Staffing Issues
Overview of OSCE experience with the nationality of monitors
Consideration
National monitor
International monitor
Monitoring
experience and
knowledge of
applicable laws
• less likely to find candidates with
monitoring experience and skills
• likely to have monitoring experience, but will still have to be trained
on programme methods and
requirements.
• need training on programme methods and requirements
• more likely to be familiar with domestic law and practice; may need
additional training on international
human rights standards
• more likely to be familiar with international human rights standards,
including on fair trial and legal practice in a foreign state; will need to
become proficient in domestic law.
Language
• can observe and review documents
without interpretation
• requires local language skills or an
interpreter.
Cost
• less expensive, as already resides in
local area and is paid at local rates
• more expensive to hire and support.
Perception of
impartiality
• less likely to be viewed as unbiased, especially where monitoring is
of post-conflict cases involving war
crimes, ethnic violence or other sectarian issues
• more likely to be viewed as an impartial observer within the goals of
the programme; however, bias may
still be attributed depending on the
monitor’s nationality or other factors.
Susceptibility to
pressure
• more likely to be deterred by access
limitations or other pressure to not
report critically
• less likely to be deterred by access
issues, given that there is no permanent connection to local actors
Capacity-building/
long-term
commitment
• likely to remain in the country with
acquired knowledge and skills
• less likely to continue working in
the country after the completion of
the project; likely, however, to continue in a monitoring, advisory or
capacity-building role in other field
operations.
• more likely to continue monitoring
for longer periods and/or subsequent projects.
61
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents