NORWEGIAN PARLIAMENTARY OMBUDSMAN
National Preventive Mechanism
ANNUAL REPORT 2020
24
Inmate’s right to healthcare during a pandemic
The prison healthcare services play an essential
role in safeguarding the health of inmates, also dur
ing a pandemic. The Ombudsman has repeatedly
noted that the capacity of the prison healthcare
services is inadequate.3 The investigation showed
that the challenges in regard to the general
capacity of the healthcare services were exacer
bated during the pandemic. Inmates experienced
greater difficulty in contacting healthcare services
during the COVID-19 pandemic than under normal
circumstances, as the healthcare services had to
prioritise emergency care.
It also appears that adverse effects from solitary
confinement and psychological strain as a result
of quarantine and solitary confinement have not
been given adequate attention. The Ombudsman
notes that inmates in quarantine and solitary
confinement are deprived of their liberty and
cannot safeguard their own interests. Therefore
it is unfortunate that inmates who have been
placed in quarantine and solitary confinement have
not received necessary supervision from prison
healthcare services. Of the fifty respondents who
stated that they had been placed in quarantine or
solitary confinement, only one stated that they had
received daily visits by the healthcare services. This
is in breach of the Mandela Rules and the WHO’s
provisional guidelines on COVID-19 in prisons,
which determine that inmates placed in solitary
confinement must be supervised daily, respectively
once or twice per day.4
—
«[...] had a conversation lasting
three minutes with the healthcare
services on the day of arrival,
but no further contact.»
Inmate
—
Doctor’s office in a prison visited by the NPM.
3
See also The Parliamentary Ombudsman's Special Report to the Storting on Solitary Confinement and Lack of Human Contact
in Norwegian Prisons, Document 4:3 (2018/19), chap.10; Parliamentary Ombudsman’s report from visit to Oslo Prison, 1922
November 2018; Arendal Prison 68 February 2018; Åna Prison, 1315 November 2017; Ullersmo Prison, 2931 August 2017; Bergen
Prison 46 November 2014.
4
Mandela Rules, rule 46 no. 1; (WHO) Europe, “Preparedness, prevention and control of COVID-19 in prisons and other places of
detention: interim guidance», 15 March 2020, p. 21.
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents