Gender and SSR Toolkit
provided for victims of violent past lives. Many of the
women in prison will need substantial counselling help to
enable them to deal with their past experiences. Many
juveniles and young people in prison come from violent
home backgrounds or have been brought up on the street
in some form of gang culture.
Dealing with these problems is essential if people from
such backgrounds are to move on to living their lives
without committing crimes and inflicting violence on
others. If such problems are not addressed, prisons will
continue to let people onto the streets upon release who
may have become even more brutalised and damaged
by their prison experiences. Many who enter prison as
minor lawbreakers may emerge as more hardened and
dangerous after release.
3.4 To promote better public health
Prisons are unhealthy places and many of those sent to
prison are in very poor health. Diseases such as
HIV/AIDS and Hepatitis B and C are much more common
amongst prisoners than in the general population
because they constitute a high percentage of poor people
with limited or no access to health care, as well as a
relatively high number of illicit drug users. Poor health
conditions in prisons and sexual violence or sexual
activity amongst prisoners can lead to the transmission of
such diseases. Policies to make condoms available in
prisons have been recommended by WHO and UNODC,
and have been adopted in some countries.25 Curbing the
prevalence of transmissible diseases in prisons is vital,
not least because prisoners take their infections home
with them to their partners and children on release.
Women in prison have particular health problems that
require specific attention. In some countries the rates of
mental illness amongst women prisoners are very high.26
Many suffer from various gynaecological conditions that
need treatment. Women may also come to prison
pregnant. In many countries, a baby born in prison may
be allowed to remain there with the imprisoned mother,
as may very young children who accompany their
mothers to prison. Prisons thus become responsible for
the protection, health and development of these children
in their earliest years.
Consequently, ensuring that prison health care policies
and practices take into account the different health needs
of women, girls, men and boys is integral to promoting
better public health.
3.5 To promote equal treatment and
participation of men and women as penal
sector staff
Women working in prison systems as employees also
face discrimination and violence. They are often
restricted to working either with women prisoners or in
administrative roles and their prospects of moving up the
hierarchy are limited. In only a few countries do women
have the same employment opportunities as men and
become directors of large prisons holding male
prisoners.
4
Reports from a number of countries suggest that women
working in prisons for men are subjected to harassment
and discrimination from their male colleagues.27 Similar
treatment is also often reported by gay and lesbian
employees.
4
How can gender be
integrated into penal reform?
However reform is conceived and carried out, attention is
needed to ensure that gender matters are considered.
Too often prison manuals and reform guidelines are
silent on the level of gender-based violence (GBV) in
prisons, the particular needs of women and juveniles,
and the discrimination prevalent in prison systems across
all regions of the world.
No prison or penal reform context is identical, and men
and women in different places have different needs. The
following are suggestions for the integration of gender
issues into penal reform, which may be adapted to the
specific context in which the reform is taking place. Some
particular challenges and opportunities that may exist in
post-conflict, transitional, developing and developed
contexts are discussed in Section 6.
4.1 Ensure that penal policies are appropriate
to both male and female prisoners
Most penal systems operate, or are expected to operate,
according to the law and to operating procedures. Little
scope is given for discretion and individualised treatment.
Rarely do sentencing guidelines incorporate any
recognition of gender differences and their implications.
Governments do not always collect the data that would
enable judgements to be made about whether policies
are appropriate to the whole population. This is
problematic considering how penal policies have often
been designed to meet the needs of male prisoners. To
ensure that policies are more appropriate and nondiscriminatory, the penal system needs to be analysed
specifically to see how it can deal fairly with all (see Box
1). Areas to consider are:
■
■
Use of pre-trial detention – Are women detained on
the basis of different criteria than those used for men –
e.g. regarding the need for psychiatric reports or
protection – when detention is not necessary? Are
family responsibilities taken into account when pre-trial
detention is being considered?
Does sentencing practice reflect gender-based
disparities? Could sentencing guidelines and advice to
the judiciary include consideration of the social impact
of the sentence on those with primary caring
responsibilities? The Russian Penal Code stipulates
that a prison sentence for a pregnant woman, or a
woman with a young child, convicted of a minor offence
is automatically suspended until the child reaches the
age of 14. If the woman concerned is not re-convicted
in the interim period, the sentence is not activated.28