-61
combine both types of methods in their monitoring.
The advantages of the quantitative methods are in the possibility to obtain
statistical and representative information from a larger number of detainees,
and to better ensure the anonymity of the respondents. Their disadvantages
are in the very basic and general type of the information obtained, and the
reduced likelihood of going into details of the particular circumstances of the
individual respondent. Qualitative methods allow much better possibility to
dig deep into the circumstances of each case. However, in order to explore
the root causes of the problems which the affected individuals and groups
face, there is often a need to use both qualitative and quantitative methods.
Quantitative methods seem to be underused by NPMs nowadays and there
are no good reasons for this. Nothing should prevent an NPM to conduct a
representative survey in a specific detention facility, or in the system of the
criminal detention as a whole. The experience of those organizations who
have carried out such surveys in the past are very positive and the results
have proven extremely valuable.
In 2016-2017, the Bulgarian Helsinki Committee carried out a survey
among 1,357 convicted prisoners in all the prisons of Bulgaria, whose
pre-trial proceedings had started after 1 January 2015. According
to the survey findings, every third person (34%) surveyed reported
being physically ill-treated either upon police arrest or in police
custody. Those
claiming
use
of
physical
force within
police
custody were more (24%) than those who reported violence
upon arrest (19.4%). The number of inmates claiming physical illtreatment at investigation detention facilities was significantly
lower – 6.2% of those who had been detained at such facilities.
In general, the survey did not reveal any positive dynamics in the
trends, and even estimated a slight increase of the use of unlawful
physical force over the past several years. The survey results revealed
that two groups are particularly in a situation of vulnerability visà-vis physical abuse by the police – Roma and juvenile prisoners.
The share of Roma (28.3%) who reported being victims of physical
abuse by police officers was twice as high as that of Bulgarians (14.5%).
Prisoners in a Situation of Vulnerability
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents