E/CN.4/1991/17
page 18
result of her presumed membership of an opposition group, for which she was
tried twice and acquitted for lack of evidence of the charges against her.
It is reported that, in October 1983, she was held incommunicado for 15 days,
during which, as stated in the complaint, she was tortured and given electric
shocks. It is also reported that, in August 1984, she was again held
incommunicado for seven days and tortured.
60. On 10 August 1990, the Government of Ecuador informed the Special
Rapporteur that: "Mrs. Cardenas Hernandez voluntarily turned herself in so
that the court proceedings lawfully interrupted by her absence could continue,
a procedure provided for by Ecuadorian law. Mrs. Cardenas' voluntary
surrender took place publicly at the Court of Constitutional Guarantees in
the presence of members of the Court and the Government Under-Secretariat,
thus clearly demonstrating that conditions of humanitarian treatment,
respect for human rights and the guarantee of an impartial trial have changed
for the better in the country since August 1988, when the Government of
Dr. Rodrigo Borja took power. In this specific case, the extended duration
of the proceedings against Mrs. Cardenas is due primarily to the fact that
Ecuadorian law requires the interruption of judicial proceedings when the
accused are not present, as in this case. Mrs. Cardenas now has the assurance
of treatment surrounded by every possible individual and procedural guarantee".
Government letters and replies
61. On 28 February 1990, the Government of Ecuador sent the Special
Rapporteur a letter replying to a communication of 17 November 1989
(E/CN.4/1990/17, para. 53) stating that the National Government is conducting
the necessary investigations into the cases referred to and assuring him that
it would make the information provided by the National Government available
as soon as the investigations were completed. It also reported that, as an
example of the activities being carried out to put an end to violations of
human rights in the country, about 20 prison guards were dismissed from their
functions for being responsible for the ill-treatment of prisoners in the
various social rehabilitation centres in the country. In addition, in order
to eliminate the ill-treatment of prisoners in rehabilitation centres, the
National Government is setting up a training school for prison guards to
prepare persons specifically for this work.
Urgent appeals
62. On 14 September 1990, the Special Rapporteur sent an urgent appeal to
the Government of Egypt concerning Khaled El Sherif, a journalist, who was
arrested on 13 August 1990 and is currently being held at Tora Prison near
El Maadi. It was alleged that Mr. El Sherif was tortured from 13 to
15 August 1990 at the=StjLte_S^cu£ijty_In,ie_liigeiice Headquarters, known as
Lazughli, and that after being transferred to Tora Prison he was taken back to
Lazughli and was again tortured for a week. A representative of the Egyptian
Organisation for Human Rights reportedly visited Mr. El Sherif and saw various
marks of torture on his body, including black scars indicating torture by
electric shocks, and cigarette burns. It was further alleged that the Tora
Prison administration failed to obey an order by the El Maadi Prosecutor to
transfer Mr. El Sherif to a clinic.
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents