E/CN.4/1991/17
page 19
Letters
63. On 6 June 1990 the Special Rapporteur addressed a letter to the
Government of Egypt transmitting information alleging that the practice of
torture and ill-treatment of detainees has continued to increase in the last
months of 1989. According to testimonies given by former detainees arbitrary
arrests and detentions without formal charges have become more common in
recent months. The methods of physical and psychological torture allegedly
resorted to in Egyptian prisons and State Security Intelligence Police,(SSIP)
centres included: beating, flogging, suspension by the wrists, ankles or
knees; electric shocks administered to sensitive areas such as the mouth,
nipples or genitals; sexual abuse, indefinite solitary confinement, stripping,
blindfolding, exposure to extreme water temperatures, temporary suffocation,
deprivation of basic necessities, such as food, water or bathroom facilities;
and threats of rape or abuse directed at the detainees' friends, family, or
relatives. It was further reported that in 1989 the practice of "aroussa",
whereby a prisoner is placed semi-naked on a cross and whipped, came back into
use in Egyptian prisons. Detention centres and prisons where torture was
alleged to be practised systematically included SSIP centres in Cairo
(Lazughli), Giza and Asyut, as well as the Tora Reception prison and the
Abu-Za'abal prison. Victims were said to have principally included activists
of opposition groups and members or sympathizers of Islamic fundamentalist
groups, but to an increasing extent simple demonstrators and children have
allegedly also been subjected to ill-treatment and torture. In some cases
the wounds reportedly inflicted, resulted in the detainee's death. It was
reported that numerous torture complaints have been filed with the office
of the Prosecutor General, but that the result was usually one of no
investigation or refusal to comment. The following cases of alleged torture
and death as a result of torture were reported:
(a) Makhlouf Abdel-Al Ahmed was arrested on 2 January 1989 by security
officers and detained at el Dahar Police Station. He was allegedly beaten on
the head, face and chest, and then sent to the Coptic hospital. He died on
8 January 1989. A forensic study concluded that the cause of death was severe
cerebral haemorrhaging as well as a collapse of the cardiac and circulatory
systems. The former reportedly resulted from beatings on the back of his head;
(b) Emad Yussef Ahmed Qandil, arrested on 4 April 1989, was allegedly
tortured at the SSIP centre in Tanta (Gharbia Governorate). Torture included
electric shocks and being suspended from an iron bar between two chairs;
(c) Mohamed Mostafa Ibrahim, a worker and elected member to the board
of directors in the Iron and Steel Company in Helwan, was arrested on
6 August 1989 in connection with a peaceful sit-in demonstration. Both he
and his colleague, Mostafa Nayed, were stripped, bound, beaten, and received
electric shocks in sensitive areas;
(d) Kamal Khalil Ibrahim, arrested with 62 other persons on
24 August 1989. Upon transferral to Abu Za'abal Prison Ibrahim and his
colleagues were subjected to a group beating by police, armed with sticks
and electric batons. It was further reported that Khalil's head was banged
against a wall until he lost consciousness;
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents