E/CN.4/1991/17
page 89
282. Additional mechanisms are under consideration. The Commission will,
during its forty-seventh session, discuss the desirability of an Optional
Protocol to the Convention against Torture, instituting a system of periodic
visits by independent experts to places of detention.
283. Much has been accomplished, but the final aim has not been achieved.
Everything seems to be there to make the campaign against torture a successful
one and nevertheless all human rights reports speak loudly of failure. All
the rules are there but they remain paper formulas instead of living in the
minds of men. The mutilated bodies found in ditches along the road and the
empty eyes of the living torture victims tell us that the campaign against
torture has to be relentlessly continued.
284. What has been accomplished has not been a waste of time and energy.
On the contrary, it is the indispensable infrastructure for this continued
campaign. The international campaign has now to be implemented on the
national level, and the only bodies which can do so in a credible way are
those which have endorsed this campaign on the international level, namely
Governments.
285. On the national level, Governments are faced with a choice among many
priorities. If they are confronted with a vociferous opposition or with an
armed insurgency the paramount priority would seem to be the stifling of that
opposition and the crushing of the insurgency. The possibility of realizing
all other priorities, such as economic development, would seem, in the eyes
of the authorities, to be completely dependent upon the realization of that
paramount priority. Therefore all other priorities are made subservient to
the paramount one. Under such circumstances torture is easily used for the
dual purpose of obtaining information and instilling terror. Torture becomes
a political tool for the realization of that paramount priority. But, since
a Government is not a monolithic entity and policy goals are pursued through
various Government branches, we often see the strange situation that one part
of Government continues to endorse the campaign against torture on the
international level, whereas at home another part practises or condones
torture as a political tool. When the Government is confronted with that
inconsistency, it usually denies it, since it is impossible to reconcile it
or to explain it away.
286. The organized world community should realize that the campaign against
torture will completely lose its credibility if this situation is allowed to
continue. New rules may be drawn up and new mechanisms may be established but
they will be to no avail as long as the glaring discrepancy between behaviour
at the international and national levels is tolerated. Governments should
realize that it is not impossible but, on the contrary, a compelling necessity
to pursue several priorities at the same time. They should learn to profit
from history's lesson that internal order ultimately can never - or at best
only temporarily - be restored and maintained at the cost of basic human
rights. During the past few years we have seen throughout the world the
downfall of regimes which had refused to take that lesson to heart. But
obviously there still are Governments which think that they will be the
exception to the rule.
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents