IV.
Police units of the Länder
According to the information that is available to the Commission of the Länder, there are
roughly 1.430 detention facilities of the Land Police nationwide. The Commission of the Länder visited eight police units of the Länder in the period under review. It addressed its visit
reports containing the recommendations to the Ministry of the Interior of the respective Federal Land.
1. Mainz 1 and Mainz 2 police stations in December 2010
The Commission of the Länder carried out inspection visits in Mainz 1 and Mainz 2 police
stations on 7 December 2010. The inspection encompassed the entire detention area of both
facilities, as well as several questioning and search rooms. Furthermore, the Commission of
the Länder examined the detention documentation of both stations. Mainz 1 police station
has two detention cells, and Mainz 2 police station has eleven detention cells in which a total
of 25 individuals can be accommodated.
Recommendations of the Commission of
the Länder
Video monitoring facilities are available in
several detention cells at Mainz 2 police station. The Commission of the Länder stresses
that the video monitoring is an encroachment
on the right to informational self-determination
as a matter of principle. It recommends in this
context to explicitly point the individuals in custody to the fact of video monitoring (for instance by affixing an appropriate pictogram).
The collection of data should furthermore be
shown by an optical or acoustic signal. The
reason and the duration of video monitoring
should be noted in the detention record. To
protect privacy, the individual monitored
should be enabled on request to visit a toilet
outside the monitored area, as provided in the
draft Act of the Land Government amending
the Police and Regulatory Authorities Act
(Landtag printed paper [Drucksache] 15/4879).
Finally, the Commission of the Länder once
more stresses that video monitoring cannot,
and should not, replace personal contact with
the individuals in custody.
Reaction of the Ministry of the Interior
and for Sport (Rhineland-Palatinate)
A variety of technical means were available in the detention facilities of the Rhineland-Palatinate Police to collect data (e.g.
video monitoring). The use of such means
is said to be based in the Police and
Regulatory Authorities Act (Polizei- und
Ordnungsbehördengesetz) of RhinelandPalatinate and the provisions contained in
the Detention Code for the Police
(No. 3.5).
The insertion of section 16 b by order of
the Rhineland-Palatinate Landtag to
amend the Police and Regulatory Authorities Act had comprehensively amended
the collection of data by use of technical
means in police detention facilities. This
entailed a revision and a new version of
the Detention Code of the RhinelandPalatinate Police. It could be assumed that
the provisions which it contained very
largely complied with the recommendations of the Commission of the Länder.
The Commission of the Länder complains that Searching the inmates before taking them
not all detention cells in Mainz 1 and Mainz 2 into custody is said to ensure, as a matter
police stations are equipped with fire alarms.
of principle, that no lighters or other means
of ignition are taken into the detention
cells. Nonetheless, networked and vandal-
65
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents