18 | Annual Report 2019
decision-making systems, robot software and
other artificial intelligence systems.
Modern technology brings significant benefits
to citizens as well as to public administration in
many ways. Automated case processing systems where computers entirely or partly make
administrative decisions can actually make the
case processing cheaper and quicker. Depending on the type of individual case, digitally generated decisions can also be of higher quality and
be more predictable.
So, there is no doubt that digitisation of the
public sector offers immense potential for our
welfare society and thus for all of us. However,
the rapid development does not only contain
positive gains but also challenges.
IT systems with problems
from day one
The Ombudsman’s core task is to ensure the
individual citizen’s legal rights when meeting the
public administration. This also applies as far as
the new digital reality is concerned.
At the same time, digital self-service solutions
can also improve the quality of the public administration’s service to citizens in a number of cases. We can benefit from a public administration
with night and day opening hours where we can
take care of our unsettled matters with public
authorities via the internet whenever convenient
for us.
The general administrative law requirements
and principles apply irrespective of manual or
digital case processing. It is therefore the individual authority’s responsibility when the case
processing is digitised fully or partially within a
field that new digital solutions meet the requirements so that citizens maintain their legal rights
(Case No. 2018-1).
Digital solutions can also improve everyday life
for citizens at many public institutions such as
schools, kindergartens, hospitals and residential
care homes. The school teacher can, for example, by means of digital teaching aids target
the teaching of the individual pupil to a higher
degree. Modern health technology enables patients to self-monitor their disease in their own
home.
Unfortunately, the Parliamentary Ombudsman
has found a number of times within recent years
that public digital solutions did not comply with
administrative law requirements.
Good digital solutions can also enhance the
efficiency of public administration and thereby
release significant resources, including the socalled ‘warm hands’ and a more citizen-friendly welfare. At the same time, digitisation has
frequently proven to be an efficient tool when
rethinking processes and working procedures in
the public sector.
The system defects have been manifold. For
instance, there have been problems with incomplete dating of letters, defects in relation to the
digital systems’ ability to retrieve relevant cases
which should, among other things, ensure uniform practice, defects in securing original contents of documents and authenticity (Case No.
2015-22) as well as insufficient record-keeping
(Case No. 2018-29).
Just like the case about the woman who wanted
to help her mother, it has unfortunately also been
found several times that a digital solution did not
comply with section 8 of the Public Administra-
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents