EN_CPT_AR.book Page 21 Monday, October 25, 2010 5:14 PM
Publication of CPT visit reports
Publication of CPT visit reports
Preliminary remarks
32. The well-established trend towards States lifting the veil of confidentiality and
publishing CPT visit reports was confirmed during the period covered by this
General Report; reports on 19 visits were published by the Committee at the request
of the governments concerned. At the time of writing, 243 of the 282 visit reports so
far drawn up have been placed in the public domain. As was emphasised in the 19th
General Report, authorising publication of visit reports can be seen as one of the
most important means of cooperating with the CPT, in view of the increased impact
it can give to the Committee’s work.
33. A State-by-State table showing the current situation as regards publication of
CPT visit reports is set out in Appendix 6. From that table it is clear that the Russian
Federation continues to constitute an exception to the above-mentioned trend. This
matter was raised with the Russian authorities during the CPT’s ad hoc visit in April
2010, and the Committee remains hopeful that they will revise their position in due
course. The CPT fully agrees with the recent comment by the Committee of
Ministers that “…the publication of [CPT visit reports and the Russian authorities’
responses] would be to the benefit of all levels of the Russian administration, nongovernmental groups and the Russian society more generally in terms of promoting
human rights protection”.3
The CPT welcomes the publication in November 2009 of the report on the
Committee’s most recent visit to Azerbaijan, in 2008, and it hopes that the
Azerbaijani authorities will also give favourable consideration to authorising
publication of the reports on the three visits from 2004 to 2006.
Further, the CPT believes that the time is now more than ripe for publication
of the Committee's report to NATO on its visit in 2007 to places of deprivation of
liberty in Kosovo4 under the authority of KFOR.
34. In most cases, the government’s response to a visit report is published at the
same time as the visit report. However, there is an increasing number of examples of
governments deciding to publish CPT visit reports promptly, without awaiting the
drawing up of their response. The Belgian, Moldovan and Swedish authorities
authorised the publication of the reports on visits to their countries in 2009, before
transmitting their response, and the Georgian authorities have very recently
proceeded in the same manner as regards the report on the visit to their country in
February 2010. Naturally, the CPT welcomes this approach.
3.
4.
Reply adopted on 16 September 2010 to Written Question No. 579 by Mrs Taktakishvili, member of the
Parliamentary Assembly.
See footnote 1 on page 8.
21
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents