E/CN.4/1999/61/Add.1
page 20
to request a transfer. Nonetheless, the Special Rapporteur is concerned that
the potential for abusive withholding of transfer requests is present,
irrespective of actual practice, and finds it desirable that such apparent
gaps in protection be closed wherever possible, not least to guard against
false allegations.
67.
With respect to the transfer of prisoners to hospitals, the Minister for
Health informed the Special Rapporteur that plans exist to build specific
hospitals in Ankara, Istanbul and Izmir exclusively for prisoners and that
prisoners on transfer are currently kept in special prisoner wards in ordinary
hospitals. According to the Minister, prisoners transferred to such hospital
wards are free to see the doctor of their choice and are treated like any
other patient. In contrast, non-official sources alleged that prisoners are
often subjected to ill-treatment during transfer, that the special sections
within hospitals are not able to provide the necessary facilities to treat
serious cases and that medical staff in the special sections may be subject to
pressure. An example was given of a case where three nurses were transferred
from a special section at the request of jandarma, who felt the nurses were
developing overly close relations with the prisoners.
68.
A final problem of note concerning prisons is the presence of a number
of prisoners with terminal diseases among inmates. Many of these, for example
a group at Istanbul Sa—macilar prison (BayrampaÕa), have developed a
degenerative condition known as Wernicke-Korsakoff syndrome as a result of
prolonged hunger strikes. Article 399 of the Code of Criminal Procedure
provides for the postponement of or reprieve from sentences for the terminally
ill. The Special Rapporteur has received many allegations that this article
is not being implemented in spite of a series of petitions by non-governmental
organizations on behalf of terminally ill prisoners. The official response,
as communicated by a non-governmental source, is reportedly that, at least in
the case of those prisoners in BayrampaÕa suffering from Wernicke-Korsakoff
syndrome, the problem is that they are on remand and cannot therefore be
pardoned as they have not yet been convicted. While this may be an accurate
legal construction of the provision, it appears inconsistent to apply a
stricter rule to those whose guilt has not yet been firmly established than to
those who have been convicted. As far as the Special Rapporteur's mandate is
concerned, the issue is not the release of these prisoners per se, but
ensuring that they receive humane treatment. If their medical condition makes
release or treatment outside prison imperative, then measures should be taken
accordingly.
III.
IMPUNITY
69.
Despite the widespread reports of torture, especially in cases involving
the enforcement of the Anti-Terror Law, investigation, prosecution and
punishment of members of security forces are rare. Human rights organizations
claim that the failure of the Turkish Government to enforce domestic and
international prohibitions of torture has led to a climate of official
impunity that encourages abuse of detainees during the detention period.
70.
The provisions of the Turkish Penal Code that criminalize torture and
ill-treatment, specifically articles 243, 245 and 354, have been outlined
above (see paras. 30-31). Other legal measures protecting against abuse by
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents