-19
Ultimately, knowledge of the world is nothing but our own personal
construction. There is no such thing as “objective” knowledge. The person
and medium of observation influence the results of the observation.
This principle has two important practical consequences.
• One has to internalize awareness that one’s own position and perspective
is only one among many others and not to be tempted to assume them
as certain.
• One has to actively seek and engage with the perspectives and interests
of other actors and take these seriously as other relevant views of reality.
Application of the principle in preventive monitoring
The importance of this principle is readily accepted in monitoring practice.
It is now common sense that conscious effort should be made to not only
interview inmates and prison management, but to constructively engage
also with prison staff, social services providers, prison psychologists,
relevant NGOs etc. in order to get their viewpoints on concrete situations
encountered, including the root causes of torture and ill-treatment,
as well as possible solutions. Also, the need to engage in “a dialogue
with other relevant national and international actors, including civil
society” for the purpose of following up to recommendations is regularly
stressed.29 However, in many countries the dialogue with civil society
could be expanded and used more systematically. This includes using the
full potential of special advisory boards/consultative councils. Overall,
systemic thinking strongly highlights the need to apply this principle in
a very methodical, conscious and self-reflective way. For that purpose, it
may be useful to explicitly evaluate the existing cooperation and consider
possibilities to improve the existing channels of communication.
Questions for monitors
•
• How much time do monitors dedicate to interviews with prison
staff, social services etc.? Does the broad choice of interlocutors
form an explicit part of the preparation of the visit?
29. CAT/OP/1/Rev.1, para. 36.
Systemic Thinking in Preventive Human Rights Monitoring
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents