National Preventive Mechanism Eighth Annual Report 2016–17
Table 1: Legislative instruments
Transfer from prison of a person who is
suffering from a mental disorder for which
medical treatment is available in the hospital
Transfer from hospital to prison following
completion of hospital medical treatment
England and
Wales
Mental Health Act 1983 Section 47, Section
48 and Section 49 (restrictions)
Northern Ireland
Mental Health (NI) Order 1986 Article 53 and Mental Health (NI) Order 1986 Articles 56
54 (removal to hospital)
and 57
Scotland
Mental Health (Care and Treatment)
(Scotland) Act 2003 Section 136
Legal and policy framework
Involuntary psychiatric treatment of people
detained in prisons is not permitted in the
UK, to safeguard detainees from potential
abuse. Instead, legislative frameworks across
the UK provide for the transfer of detainees
who require assessment and treatment
for mental disorder to hospital, and their
subsequent return to prison when the health
episode is completed (see Table 1).
Codes of practice guide appropriate care
and treatment under relevant legislation
in England, Wales and Scotland and one is
being drafted in Northern Ireland.104
To effect the transfer of a person from
a prison to a hospital and vice versa, a
transfer direction is required to provide legal
authority. In England and Wales the transfer
direction is provided by the Secretary of
State for Justice, in Northern Ireland the
Minister of Justice and in Scotland by the
Scottish Ministers. There is no right to
appeal for prisoners who do not want to
Mental Health Act 1983 Section 50
Mental Health (Care and Treatment)
(Scotland) Act 2003 Section 216(2)
[Revocation by Scottish Ministers]
be transferred from prison to hospital,
although some patients (including all patients
transferred from prison in Scotland) can
apply to a tribunal to revoke the transfer
once it has taken effect.
After the recommendation in the Bradley
report that prisoners requiring hospital
assessment and treatment should be
transferred from prison to hospital within 14
days, guidelines were introduced in England
and Wales with the intention that a prisoner
should be transferred to a mental health
unit within 14 days of the first medical
recommendation for transfer.105 During this
14 days, a second medical opinion was to be
sought and all administrative tasks, including
finding a bed, should also be completed. In
Scotland, once the Direction has been signed
by Scottish Ministers, the transfer must
take place within seven days, although the
Act does not specify a time period before
the application for a Direction must be
determined.
104. England and Wales: Mental Health Act 1983: Code of Practice (2015) chapter 22. Scotland: Mental Health (Care and
Treatment) (Scotland) Act Code of Practice, Volume 3: Compulsory Powers in Relation to Mentally Disordered Offenders.
105. Department of Health, 2011, The transfer and remission of adult prisoners under s47 and s48 of the Mental Health Act.
40
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents