Section two Focus on detention issues
Case study – HMP Bristol: a mixed
picture
During its 2017 inspection of HMP Bristol
(Category B men’s prison), HMI Prisons
identified very good links between the
prison’s mental health service provider and
the local NHS medium secure unit (MSU).
The prison psychiatrist also practiced at
the MSU and a forensic psychiatrist from
the MSU attended the weekly prison
health multidisciplinary meeting, which
kept the prison on the MSU’s agenda. As
a result, transfer times to the unit were
reasonably good. This was not the case for
transfers to high secure units or MSUs that
were further away. The transfer time was
being counted from when a bed became
available, which is not compatible with
the 14-day guideline. HMI Prisons noted
that most prisoners were admitted to a
hospital within two to four weeks, but
between April 2016 and February 2017,
six out of 14 transfers had taken longer
than five weeks to complete.
Capacity in secure mental health services
Across the UK, capacity constraints in secure
mental health services hinder the pathway
from prisons and lead to prisoners being
transferred across jurisdictions.
In Northern Ireland, the lack of a local
high secure hospital means that some
prisoners are sent to Carstairs (in Scotland)
or Ashworth, Broadmoor or Rampton (in
England).124 Similarly in Wales there are no
high secure hospital beds.
Successive inspections by HMIPS have
identified delays in transfers from prisons
for women and men due to the insufficient
provision of medium secure hospital beds
in Scotland. The absence of high secure
mental health beds for female prisoners
has been identified as an area of concern in
Scotland by the MWCS. The matter is under
consideration by the Scottish Government,
although the way forward has not been
agreed.
In England, there are insufficient secure
mental health beds to meet demand.125 Lack
of access to secure hospital beds is the most
frequently cited reason for delayed transfers
from prison to secure mental health services.
The NPM is aware that there are aspirations
to increase capacity but this will not be
achieved for several years.
Transfers at the end of prison sentences
The failure to effect transfers before a
prisoner has completed his or her sentence
means that opportunities to prevent mental
deterioration through appropriate treatment
may have been missed and/or the public
placed at risk. One NPM member identified
three cases where prisoners had been
released before the prison had completed
the process for transfer to a secure hospital.
This was of concern because the prisoners
in question had suspected mental disorders
which may have responded to treatment
and/or a mental disorder which may have
been a factor in the offence/alleged offence.
124. Criminal Justice Inspectorate Northern Ireland, 2010, Not a Marginal Issue: Mental Health and the Criminal Justice System
in Northern Ireland, http://www.cjini.org/getattachment/24d6cd45-20bb-4f81-9e34-81ea59594650/Mental-Health-andthe-criminal-justice-in-Northern.aspx [accessed 13/11/17].
125. Department of Health, 2000, The NHS Plan, A plan for investment, A plan for reform, page 118.
45
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents