THEMATIC REPORT 2017
REDRESS AND REPARATIONS
SUMMARY
This report uses data collected by IRCT member centres in
Kenya, Mexico, the Philippines, Serbia and Uganda over the
course of the Data in the Fight against Impunity (DFI) project
to illustrate some of the challenges faced by torture victims to
access redress and reparations.
The data illustrates that even in countries where legislation
to prevent and criminalise torture or to provide redress to
victims has been enacted, torture victims still face challenges in
accessing redress and reparations. There have been few, if any,
convictions of perpetrators compared to the number of torture
victims who have filed a complaint about torture. Complaints
are often not investigated promptly, effectively or impartially
and in many instances the documentation of the physical and
psychological effects of torture on the victim is not carried out
to the internationally accepted standards laid out in the Istanbul
Protocol. This is despite there being clear obligations on states
to enact legislation and establish mechanisms to effectively
investigate and prosecute torture complaints.
The data further shows that very few victims have been
awarded reparations, such as compensation or rehabilitation,
through a court process; and where compensation is awarded,
the payments are often not made to the victims. Moreover, the
provision of rehabilitation services by states still does not exist
in the majority of the countries in this report, or is not being
effectively implemented. As a result, torture victims in all five
countries rely heavily on the specialised rehabilitation services
provided by IRCT member centres in the absence of adequate
State services. This is despite clear international, regional
and often domestic legal obligations on states to provide
mechanisms for torture victims to access reparation, including
compensation and rehabilitation. The data also illustrates
various barriers for torture victims to access redress and
reparations, including: lengthy court processes, the fear of
reprisals and intimidation made worse by a lack of protection
mechanisms and statutory limitation periods for filing
complaints.
The ability of torture victims to access redress and reparations
plays an important role in the fight against impunity. There
is a danger that where there are non-existent or ineffective
mechanisms to complain about, investigate and prosecute
acts of torture and no effective means for the victims to seek
reparations a culture of impunity and acceptance of torture
will be perpetuated.
page 5
Torture victims in all
five countries rely
heavily on the specialised
rehabilitation services
provided by IRCT member
centres in the absence of
adequate State services.
This is despite clear
international, regional
and often domestic legal
obligations on states to
provide mechanisms for
torture victims to access
reparation, including
compensation and
rehabilitation.