A/HRC/4/33/Add.3
page 27
forced to repeatedly stand and squat; and having cigarettes stubbed out against the skin. Officers
were reported to draw faucets or ladders on walls or on the ground, which inmates would have to
pretend to drink or climb up. Prisoners described being forced to kiss walls, furniture or the
shoes of officers, eat food from a guard’s shoes, shout slogans, and forced to call themselves
insulting names.
9.
The detainees described how newly arrived detainees would be met by a “welcoming
committee” of up to 20 officers. In the courtyard outside their assigned barracks, the new
arrivals would be forced to strip to their underwear and be subjected to beatings by the officers
with electrical cables and batons while still handcuffed. The beatings would last for long periods
at a time. The detainees would be revived with cold water and beaten again, and this treatment
would last for days. No medical treatment was provided for the injuries. Additionally, they
would be placed in solitary confinement cells, where they would be subjected to further beatings.
10.
In one cell block several detainees alleged similar beatings with cabling. The medical
examination of the forensic expert revealed that one detainee showed yellowing red “rail-track”
bruising with associated abrasions together with circular bruising and central abrasion over the
upper half of the back, strongly corroborative of an allegation of beating with cabling. A second
detainee showed similar “rail-track” scabbed abrasions horizontally to the lumbar area of the
back and both shoulders where there were also irregular areas of fresh scarring strongly
corroborative of the allegation of a routine beating. A third detainee who had arrived three days
previously from another facility had an area of discontinuous scabbed abrasions down the outer
aspect of the right forearm and onto the back of the right hand and adjacent little finger, a pattern
of injury consistent with the allegation that they were sustained while warding off blows
(defensive-type injuries). The right hand was swollen and there were minimal wrist and finger
movements. A prominent area of scabbing overlay the first knuckle of the right ring finger
which was extremely tender, displaced and likely fractured. A fourth detainee displayed a
scattering of fresh healing “rail-track” abrasions to the upper back and left outer arm again
strongly corroborative of the allegation of a beating. A fifth detainee showed similar healing
“rail-track” abrasions with associated yellowing pink bruising and irregular areas of abrasion to
the upper back. A sixth detainee who alleged that he had been beaten four months previously
displayed hyper-pigmented “rail-track” scarring to the back of the right shoulder and circular
areas of hyper-pigmented scarring to both shoulders consistent with the time frame of the
allegation. He also displayed on his right upper arm a horizontal area of discontinuous
“rail-track” fresh pink bruising supportive of his allegation of a very recent assault. A seventh
detainee who alleged he was beaten using cabling had irregular areas of young scarring and
healing abrasions over the upper back and outer aspect of the left upper arm together with more
recent linear scabbed abrasions to the inner aspect of the right thigh consistent with the allegation
of two episodes of beatings.
11.
Taken together the character, distribution and age of the injuries to these seven detainees
provided compelling corroboration of their allegations of routine beatings as an institutional
procedure. Many of the detainees also had multiple parallel linear scars, typical of self-inflicted
cut wounds, to predominantly the arms and legs. They freely admitted, without prompting, that
these scars were from injuries which they had inflicted upon themselves out of a sense of
frustration.
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents