22
Intrusive and detrimental to health
Being placed in a restraint bed is a major violation
on personal integrity, and creates a risk of somatic
injuries, trauma and other negative consequences
to mental health.
Somatic risks include dehydration, circulation
and skin problems, loss of muscle strength and
mobility and incontinence. It also entails a risk of
death as a result of blood clots.11 Two fatalities
have occurred during or after the use of restraints
in mental healthcare institutions in Norway in the
past 25 years: one as a result of a blood clot
in 1998, and one due to cardiac arrest in 2011.
In Denmark, a death was reported in 2016 as a
result of a blood clot shortly after the use of a
restraint bed in prison.12
We know that the use of restraints in mental
healthcare institutions pose a risk of personal
injury. Such injuries can occur during the initial
phase of the application of the restraint, due
to lack of supervision, the inmate being placed
in the bed for an excessive amount of time, or
other reasons, such as body parts being trapped
prior to application of the restraint, or aggressive
behaviour from staff. In an attempt to control
the inmate, the staff may overreact, thus leading
to heavy-handed and painful use of force.13
NORWEGIAN PARLIAMENTARY OMBUDSMAN
National Preventive Mechanism
ANNUAL REPORT 2019
The person put in the restraint bed will react with
fear and panic, which is normal in this situation
as he or she may feel that they are fighting for their
life. Aggressive reactions from staff can result in
conduct that escalates the conflict and constitutes
a greater risk of injuries.14
There is also a considerable risk of negative mental
health consequences. Feelings of powerlessness,
helplessness, loneliness, fear and re-traumatisation
are reported. In addition to the immediate harmful
effects, being put in a restraint bed can lead to
negative long-term effects, such as traumatising
memories, feelings of mistrust and symptoms
of post-traumatic stress disorder.15 Studies
also show that experiences of harmful coercive
events are made worse when there is a sense of
miscommunication in the situation, such as the
feeling of not being taken seriously, humiliated or
being punished. Such negative experiences can
last for several years after the event.16, 17
Because inmates are placed in restraints when
they harm themselves or attempt suicide, there is
reason to believe that there is an increased risk of
such long-term effects. It can thus be concluded
that inmates who are placed in restraint beds are
subjected to an intervention that entails a clear risk
of developing trauma in an acute life crisis.
11 Norwegian Official Report NOU 2019:14 (2019). Draft Law on the Reduction of Coercive Measures [Tvangsbegrensningsloven].
Oslo: Norwegian Government Security and Service Organisation, p. 267.
12 Ankerstjerne, (2018) Young man in restraint bed for 9 days in Vridsløselolle - died few days after release [Ung mand lå fastspændt
i 9 døgn i Vridsløselille - døde få dage efter], TV2Lorry.no, 14. mars 2018. Available from:
https://www.tv2lorry.dk/albertslund/ung-mand-la-fastspaendt-i-9-dogn-i-vridsloselille-dode-fa-dage-efter
13 Norwegian Official Report NOU 2019:14 (2019). Draft Law on the Reduction of Coercive Measures [Tvangsbegrensningsloven].
Oslo: Norwegian Government Security and Service Organisation, p. 265.
14 Norwegian Official Report NOU 2019:14 (2019). Draft Law on the Reduction of Coercive Measures [Tvangsbegrensningsloven].
Oslo: Norwegian Government Security and Service Organisation, p. 265.
15 Norwegian Official Report NOU 2019:14 (2019). Draft Law on the Reduction of Coercive Measures [Tvangsbegrensningsloven].
Oslo: Norwegian Government Security and Service Organisation, p. 267.
16 Norwegian Official Report NOU 2011:9 (2011). More self-determination and legal safeguards. Oslo: Norwegian Government
Security and Service Organisation, p. 124.
17 Strout, T.D. (2010). Perspectives on the experience of being physically restrained: An integrative review of the qualitative literature.
International journal of mental health nursing, 19, 416–427.
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents