8
CPT: 14TH GENERAL REPORT
ACTIVITIES DURING THE PERIOD
1 AUGUST 2003 TO 31 JULY 2004
Visits
1.
The CPT organised twenty-two visits totalling
169 days during the twelve-month period covered by
this General Report1. Pending further reinforcement of
its Secretariat, the Committee has been obliged for the
time being to maintain its annual visit programme at
the 170-day level; however, an increase in the number
of visit days will soon be possible (cf. paragraph 24).
Of the twenty-two visits, ten (totalling 100
days) formed part of the CPT’s annual programme of
periodic visits and twelve (69 days) were ad hoc visits
which the Committee considered were required by the
circumstances.
2.
The following countries received periodic
visits during the period 1 August 2003 to 31 July 2004:
Andorra, Austria, Croatia, Estonia, Finland, Georgia,
Iceland, Lithuania, Portugal and Turkey.
During the remaining months of 2004, five
more periodic visits will be organised – to Cyprus,
Italy, Moldova, Poland and, for the first time, to Serbia
and Montenegro.
3.
Specific reference should be made to the
periodic visit to Georgia, which had to be organised
in two stages, in November 2003 and May 2004.
At the time of the outset of the visit (the dates
of which had been fixed several months beforehand), a
political crisis had developed in the aftermath of the
parliamentary elections of 2 November 2003 and the
country was in turmoil due to almost daily
demonstrations. The CPT nevertheless decided to
maintain the visit; indeed, it was felt that given the
nature of the Committee’s mandate, the presence of the
delegation at that moment would be particularly
appropriate. However, in the light of the situation, the
delegation had to adapt its programme, in particular as
regards travel outside Tbilisi. Consequently, a
continuation of the visit was planned for May 2004, the
main objective being to examine the treatment of
persons detained in Adjara.
Once again, the visit coincided with important
events, namely a critical political and security situation
which had arisen following the destruction of bridges
connecting Adjara with other parts of the country.
1
The countries and places of detention visited are set
out in Appendix 7.
Despite this, and for the same reasons as in November
2003, the visit was maintained, and the delegation
arrived in Batumi the day after the introduction of
direct Presidential rule.
Notwithstanding inevitable complications
caused by the above-mentioned events, the delegation
was able to carry out the visit according to the CPT’s
mandate and its consultations with the competent
national authorities took place in a spirit of close
cooperation.
4.
The twelve ad hoc visits carried out by the
CPT during the period covered by this General Report
concerned the following countries: Armenia,
Azerbaijan, Bulgaria, Latvia, Malta, Moldova (two
visits), Romania, Switzerland, “the former Yugoslav
Republic of Macedonia”, Turkey and the United
Kingdom.
The circumstances which led to the
organisation of these visits varied considerably. Some
of them were carried out in order to verify the
implementation in practice of recommendations
previously made by the CPT concerning issues of
particular importance. Others were triggered by recent
reports concerning the situation of persons deprived of
their liberty. In one case, namely the visits to Moldova,
the CPT’s intervention took place very much at the
instigation of the national authorities, which requested
the Committee’s assistance in attempts to break a longrunning deadlock concerning Prison No. 8 in Bender.
5.
Prison No. 8 in Bender forms part of the
penitentiary system of the Republic of Moldova, but is
located in an area under the control of the Transnistrian
region (which unilaterally declared itself an
independent republic in 1991). In July 2003 the Bender
municipal authorities cut off the supply of running
water and electricity to the prison; they claimed that
the establishment represented a significant tuberculosis
risk to the surrounding Bender community and wished
to see it vacated. During ad hoc visits to Moldova in
November 2003 and February 2004, the CPT’s
delegation examined the situation in Prison No. 8 and
held talks with all relevant authorities, in order to
explore ways of ending the impasse which had arisen.
In this context it was emphasised that any attempt to
impose a settlement of differences by bringing about
hardship
to
prisoners
deserves
unqualified
condemnation.