E/CN.4/1995/31/Add.3
page 3
Introduction
1.
The Working Group on Arbitrary Detention, represented by its
Chairman-Rapporteur, Mr. L. Joinet, and by two of its members, Mr. L. Kama
and Mr. K. Sibal, visited Bhutan from 17 to 22 October 1994. The visit was
pursuant to an invitation by the Royal Government of Bhutan, contained in a
letter dated 8 August 1994 from the Permanent Representative of the Kingdom of
Bhutan to the United Nations Office at Geneva addressed to the Working Group’s
Chairman-Rapporteur. By that letter, the Working Group was invited to visit
Bhutan "in connection with the alleged case of arbitrary detention which is
presently being considered by the Working Group". The reference is to the
case of Tek Nath Rizal, submitted by the Working Group to the Bhutanese
Government on 14 October 1991, which has been the subject of a lengthy
correspondence and exchange of information between the Government and the
Working Group and regarding which the Working Group has not yet adopted a
decision. While it was clear that the Working Group, in the course of its
visit to Bhutan, would examine the above-mentioned case, it was also obvious
that the scope of the visit would not be limited to one particular case, but
would concern other problems pertaining to the Working Group’s mandate. The
Government of the Kingdom of Bhutan promised the Working Group, and indeed
extended to it, its full cooperation in facilitating its mission to the
country.
2.
During its visit to Bhutan, the Working Group stayed in the region of
the capital, Thimphu. It was granted two audiences with H.M. King Jigme
Singye Wangchuck. It was received by, and held talks with the Foreign
Minister, Lyonpo Dawa Tsering; the Home Minister, Lyonpo Dago Tshering;
the Minister of Trade and Industry, Lyonpo Om Pradhan; the Chief Justice,
Dasho Sonam Tobgye; the Speaker of the National Assembly, Dasho Pasang Dorji;
the Chairman of the Royal Advisory Council, Dasho Karma Letho, accompanied by
the other members of the Council; the Chief of the Royal Army and Police,
Goongloen Gom (Lieutenant General) Lam Dorji; and the Chief of the Royal
Bhutan Police, Colonel Tandin Dorji, accompanied by the Chief of the Special
Branch in the Royal Bhutan Police, Major Kipchu Mangyal.
3.
In addition
the two principal
Thimphu Detention
the Working Group
as it wished.
to the above-mentioned discussions, the Working Group visited
prison or detention facilities in the Thimphu district: the
Centre and the Chamgang Central Jail. In both facilities
was able to interview freely and privately as many detainees
4.
The Working Group also held informal meetings with a number of
representatives of international non-governmental organizations dealing with
technical assistance, as well as several United Nations agencies operating in
the country, who briefed the Working Group about their experience in the
country.
5.
The Working Group would like to express its gratitude to the authorities
of the Kingdom of Bhutan for the help and cooperation extended to its members
during their visit to the country.