E/CN.4/1995/34
page 38
188. Hazim Mohammad Nour al-Din Hafiz Wahdan was reportedly arrested
on 18 February 1993 and tortured for two hours each day for five days. He was
allegedly subjected to electric shocks on various parts of his body, including
to his penis and rectum. The Government replied that he had been acquitted of
charges against him by the court and that the DPP referred him for two medical
examinations. The first examination revealed a number of contusions having
occurred at a time consistent with that of the alleged incident, but these
could not have been caused by electric shocks as the defendant alleged. It
was impossible to determine the date of other abrasion injuries. The second
report indicated that the injuries mentioned in the first report had
disappeared, making it impossible to determine their cause and rendering the
complainant’s allegations unsupported.
189. Muhsin ’Ali Mursi Shahhata was arrested on 28 January 1993 and allegedly
tortured by means of electric shocks applied to various parts of his body.
The Government replied that he was sentenced to 15 years’ hard labour in
Military Felony Case 18/1993 and that, according to the medical reports,
lesions on his forearms had been caused by friction with one or more blunt
rough-surfaced objects and could not have been caused by electric shocks.
A lesion behind his right ear was a pathological condition.
190. Mohamed Ali Mohamed El-Sayed Hegazi was allegedly tortured
from 8 February 1993 through 25 February 1993, with beatings to the head with
a hard instrument and whippings on the feet and legs with a lash-like
instrument. He was said to have sustained injuries and scars to his head,
legs and shoulders (forensic report 807/1993). The Government replied that
the Department of Forensic Medicine report stated that his contusions could
have been caused in the manner alleged by the defendant. The court in
Military Felony Case 24/1993 studied the contents of the medical report
and acquitted the defendant on the ground of lack of admissible evidence
against him.
191. Ihab Abdel-Maqsoud was allegedly assaulted in prison on his left arm with
a leather instrument, subjected to electric shocks causing injury to his neck,
had tear gas canisters hurled at him and was beaten with canes (forensic
report 220/1993). The Government replied that the medical report indicated
that the abrasion observed on his forearm had been caused by the frictional
impact of some type of hard, blunt object that might have been a leather belt
as alleged in the defendant’s statement and might have occurred on the date
alleged. The court in Military Felony Case 24/1993 studied the report and
decided to sentence him to a term of three years’ imprisonment.
192. Islam Ragab abdel-Hadi was allegedly tortured by means of suspension by
the hands (forensic report 220/1993). The Government replied that he was
acquitted by the court in Military Felony Case 24/1993, which included in its
substantiating grounds the suspicion that he might have been subjected to
duress or pressure. The DPP was investigating the allegations.
193. Youssef Sadiq Youssef was allegedly tortured by an officer of the SSI
on 21 January 1993 by means of blindfolding and beatings with a whip or lash
(forensic report 122/1993). The Government replied that he had been sentenced
to 10 years’ imprisonment with hard labour in Military Felony Case 23/1993 and
that the medical report indicated that a superficial examination of his body
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents