E/CN.4/1995/34
page 86
given only perfunctory and inadequate medical treatment. One such case was
that of Nagata Hiroko, whose 1982 death sentence was confirmed by the
Supreme Court in February 1993. In 1984 she had undergone an operation for a
brain tumour but continued to suffer pain and fainting spells. By May 1993
she was reportedly so weak that she could barely walk unaided and for several
consecutive days she suffered prolonged vomiting spells, despite which she was
refused a change of clothes. Although she was in need of sustained medical
attention and requested to be hospitalized, this request was allegedly
refused.
450. The Government stated that since her
periodic examination by brain surgeons and
the same. Although she complained in 1993
only 5 cc in volume and it did not include
evidence supports that she had requested a
operation Nagata Hiroko had received
her condition remained more or less
that she had vomited, the vomit was
the contents of her stomach. No
change of clothes at that time.
451. The Special Rapporteur transmitted another letter to the Government
on 10 October 1994 concerning the case of Yoichi Isoe, aged 50, who reportedly
has been held in solitary confinement since September 1982 in Asahikawa prison
in Hokkaido. His placement in solitary confinement was not ordered pursuant
to any infraction, but may have been undertaken in retaliation for three
lawsuits he had filed against the detention centre in which he had previously
been held. The only person he spoke to was his lawyer, about three or four
times a year, in conversations always monitored by a guard present and only in
regard to his lawsuit. Speaking or other vocalization was said to be strictly
forbidden in solitary confinement, and Mr. Isoe reportedly was experiencing
difficulty in speaking during his meetings with his lawyer. Although he was
permitted one 30-minute family visit per month, his only living relative is an
elderly mother for whom it was extremely difficult to travel to the prison,
which is located on an island a great distance from where she lives. She had
reportedly visited him only twice during his stay in prison.
452. The Government replied that it refrained from disclosing facts regarding
specific cases of treatment of inmates in penal institutions in order to
protect the rights, the honour and privacy of the concerned. Generally, the
purpose of solitary confinement is to protect the inmates who have trouble
associating with others or have difficulties in living in a group because of
their physical disabilities. It has made correctional treatment more
effective and has contributed to the protection of inmates and officers.
Jordan
Information transmitted to the Government and replies received
453. By letter dated 5 August 1994 the Special Rapporteur advised the
Government that he had received information indicating that persons detained
by the General Intelligence Department (GID) were almost invariably held in
incommunicado detention, sometimes for weeks or months. They were said to be
held without access to lawyers or judges until their interrogation was
concluded and a confession, if required, was taken. Under the Code of
Criminal Procedure, public prosecutors were reportedly permitted to renew
indefinitely the detention of suspects for periods of up to 15 days at a
time and could forbid all contacts with detainees for renewable periods of
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents