E/CN.4/1995/34
page 39
had shown no traces of injuries or marks suggesting that he might have been
subjected to violence or assault. A mark on his nose might have been caused
by his being blindfolded.
194. Hilal Osman Mursi Hilal was allegedly assaulted by officials in Marg
prison on 21 May 1993. He was said to have been bound in iron clasps,
suspended from a wall, beaten on the back with an army boot and an electric
cable and hit on the back of the head (forensic report 833/1993). The
Government replied that he had been sentenced to seven years’ imprisonment in
Military Felony Case 24/1993 and that the substantiating grounds for the
judgement made no reference to assault or torture.
195. Tarek Mansour Ali was allegedly tortured by being punched, kicked and
subjected to electric shocks to his chest while blindfolded and naked
(forensic report 245/1993). The Government replied that the medical report
stated that it was impossible to determine the cause of a superficial wound on
his chin that was in the process of healing or to determine the manner in
which it had occurred. It was possible that it had occurred on the date
alleged. In reviewing all the evidence, including the contents of the report,
the court decided to acquit him in Military Felony Case 24/1993.
196. Gamal Mohamed Abu Zaid was allegedly assaulted by SSI officers, resulting
in wounds to his forehead, legs and feet (forensic report 270/1993). The
Government replied that the medical report indicated that most of the marks
observed on his body were probably recent superficial contusions and abrasions
that were not of a special or significant nature and did not support his
statement to the DPP concerning the alleged incident.
197. Khalifa Abu Zaid Shabib was allegedly tortured by having his wrists
bound, being suspended from a door and being punched and beaten with various
instruments (forensic report 261/1993). The Government replied that he was
acquitted by the court in Military Felony Case 24/1993, which included in its
substantiating grounds the suspicion that he might have been subjected to
duress or pressure. The DPP was investigating the allegations.
198. Amr Ali Mohammed El-Iraqi was allegedly assaulted upon his arrest
on 12 February 1993. He was said to have been beaten with a stick on his feet
and head and punched and slapped in the face (forensic report 221/1993). The
Government replied that the medical report indicated that marks observed on
the soles of his feet were contusions that could have originated on the date
alleged and might have been caused by beating of the feet with sticks. The
military court in Military Felony Case 24/1993 reviewed all the evidence,
including the contents of the medical report, and decided to acquit him.
199. Hasan Mekkawi Hasan Mekkaw was arrested on 10 June 1992 and interrogated
on 14 December 1992. He was allegedly tortured and suffered severe injury,
including a perforated right ear drum. The case was identified in forensic
report 600/1992. The Government replied that the court in Military Felony
Case 6/1993 had acquitted him after reviewing all the facts of the case,
including the medical report.
200. Hamidh Qasim El-Abed was arrested on 16 August 1992 and taken to the SSI
branch office in Bandar Qena. He was allegedly blindfolded, beaten and
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents